Characteristics of E-waste Recycling Systems in Japan and China

This study aims to identify processes, current situations, and issues of recycling systems for four home appliances, namely, air conditioners, television receivers, refrigerators, and washing machines, among e-wastes in China and Japan for understanding and comparison of their characteristics. In accordance with results of a literature search, review of information disclosed online, and questionnaire survey conducted, conclusions of the study boil down to: (1)The results show that in Japan most of the home appliances mentioned above have been collected through home appliance recycling tickets, resulting in an issue of “requiring some effort" in treatment and recycling stages, and most plants have contracted out their e-waste recycling. (2)It is found out that advantages of the recycling system in Japan include easiness to monitor concrete data and thorough environmental friendliness ensured while its disadvantages include illegal dumping and export. It becomes apparent that advantages of the recycling system in China include a high reuse rate, low treatment cost, and fewer illegal dumping while its disadvantages include less safe reused products, environmental pollution caused by e-waste treatment, illegal import, and difficulty in obtaining data.

Authors:

• Bi Bo
• Kayoko Yamamoto

Keywords:

• E-waste
• Recycling Systems
• Home Appliances
• Japan and China.

References:

[1] A.Terazono, Material Flow of E-waste in Japan and Other Asia, Report of
the Fourth NIES Workshop on E-waste held by National Institute for
Environmental Studies, pp.55-65, 2007.
[2] H. Du. B. Li, W. C. Fang and H. G. Yang, Recycling System and Social
Issues on E-waste in China, Report of the Fourth NIES Workshop on
E-waste held by National Institute for Environmental Studies, pp.67-76,
2007.
[3] Jain, Inventory Studies, Risk Profiling, and Financial Viability of a
Proposed E-Waste Treatment Facility in India, Proceedings of the Fourth
NIES Workshop on E-Waste, pp.89-98, 2007.
[4] S. Shrihar, E-Waste Management in Developing Countries -a case Study
of Mangalore City, Karnataka, India, Proceedings of Waste -The Social
Context'08, P.10 (CD-ROM), 2008.
[5] Hengrasmee, The E-Waste Management System in Thailand",
Proceedings of The Fourth NIES Workshop on E-Waste, pp.191-196,
2007.
[6] T. Wagner, Maine's Shared Responsibility Program for E-waste
Management, Proceedings of Waste -The Social Context '08, P.11
(CD-ROM), 2008.
[7] T. Yoshikawa, T. Tabata, H. Shirakawa and H. Imura, Study on grasp and
rationalization of material flow of the e-waste between Japan and China,
Journal of Society of Environmental Science, Japan, Vol.20, No.4,
pp.265-278, 2007.
[8] K. Nakajima, Raising the Resource Potential of E-waste -Recycle Flow
Analysis of End-of-Life Cellular Phone-, Report of the Fourth NIES
Workshop on E-waste held by National Institute for Environmental
Studies, pp.7-14, 2007.
[9] A. Terazono, Current Status and Issues of E-waste in Asia, Seikatsu to
Kankyo, Vol.51, No.6, pp.22-30, 2006.
[10] Edited by Association for Electric Home Appliances, Report of Findings
from Inspection Tour to China in FY 2007, Tokyo, 2007.
[11] B. Bo, A study on the evaluation of the recycling systems of e-waste in
China and Japan, Master thesis presented to Graduate School of
Information Systems, The University of Electro-Communications, Tokyo,
2009.