An Overview of Islanding Detection Methods in Photovoltaic Systems

The issue of unintentional islanding in PV grid interconnection still remains as a challenge in grid-connected photovoltaic (PV) systems. This paper discusses the overview of popularly used anti-islanding detection methods, practically applied in PV grid-connected systems. Anti-islanding methods generally can be classified into four major groups, which include passive methods, active methods, hybrid methods and communication base methods. Active methods have been the preferred detection technique over the years due to very small non-detected zone (NDZ) in small scale distribution generation. Passive method is comparatively simpler than active method in terms of circuitry and operations. However, it suffers from large NDZ that significantly reduces its performance. Communication base methods inherit the advantages of active and passive methods with reduced drawbacks. Hybrid method which evolved from the combination of both active and passive methods has been proven to achieve accurate anti-islanding detection by many researchers. For each of the studied anti-islanding methods, the operation analysis is described while the advantages and disadvantages are compared and discussed. It is difficult to pinpoint a generic method for a specific application, because most of the methods discussed are governed by the nature of application and system dependent elements. This study concludes that the setup and operation cost is the vital factor for anti-islanding method selection in order to achieve minimal compromising between cost and system quality.

Authors:

• Wei Yee Teoh
• Chee Wei Tan

Keywords:

• Active method
• hybrid method
• islanding detection
• passive method
• photovoltaic (PV)
• utility method

References:

[1] Mulhausen, J., et al. Anti-islanding today, successful islanding in the
future. in Protective Relay Engineers, 2010 63rd Annual Conference for.
2010.
[2] Thomas Ackermann, Göran Andersson, and Lennart Söder, Distributed
generation: a definition. Electric Power Systems Research, 2001. 57(3):
p. 195-204.
[3] IEEE Recommended Practice for Utility Interface of Photovoltaic (PV)
Systems, in IEEE Std 929-20002000.
[4] IEEE, IEEE Application Guide for IEEE Std 1547, IEEE Standard for
Interconnecting Distributed Resources with Electric Power Systems.
IEEE Std 1547.2-2008, 2009: p. 1-207.
[5] IEA International Energy Agency, Evaluation of Islanding Detection
Methods for Photovoltaic Utility Interactive Power systems, in Task V
Report IEA PVPS T509: 20022002.
[6] IEEE, IEEE Standard for Interconnecting Distributed Resources With
Electric Power Systems. IEEE Std 1547-2003, 2003: p. 0_1-16.
[7] Funabashi, T., K. Koyanagi, and R. Yokoyama. A review of islanding
detection methods for distributed resources. in Power Tech Conference
Proceedings, 2003 IEEE Bologna. 2003.
[8] Singam, B. and L.Y. Hui. Assessing SMS and PJD Schemes of Anti-
Islanding with Varying Quality Factor. in Power and Energy
Conference, 2006. PECon '06. IEEE International. 2006.
[9] Velasco, D., et al., Review of anti-islanding techniques in distributed
generators. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2010. 14(6): p.
1608-1614.
[10] Noor, F., R. Arumugam, and M.Y. Vaziri. Unintentional islanding and
comparison of prevention techniques. in Power Symposium, 2005.
Proceedings of the 37th Annual North American. 2005.
[11] Wilsun Xu, Konrad Mauch, and Sylvain Martel, An Assessment of
Distributed Generation Islanding Detection Methods and Issues for
Canada. report # CETC-Varennes 2004-074 (TR), CANMET Energy
Technology Centre - Varennes, Natural Resources Canada, July 2004,
53 pp., 2004.
[12] Xuancai, Z., et al. Analysis of the Non-detection Zone with Passive
Islanding Detection Methods for Current Control DG System. in Applied
Power Electronics Conference and Exposition, 2009. APEC 2009.
Twenty-Fourth Annual IEEE. 2009.
[13] Zhihong, Y., et al., Evaluation of anti-islanding schemes based on
nondetection zone concept. Power Electronics, IEEE Transactions on,
2004. 19(5): p. 1171-1176.
[14] De Mango, F., et al. Overview of Anti-Islanding Algorithms for PV
Systems. Part I: Passive Methods. in Power Electronics and Motion
Control Conference, 2006. EPE-PEMC 2006. 12th International. 2006.
[15] Pukar Mahat, Chen Zhe, and Birgitte Bak-Jensen. Review of islanding
detection methods for distributed generation. in Electric Utility
Deregulation and Restructuring and Power Technologies, 2008. DRPT
2008. Third International Conference on. 2008.
[16] Trujillo, C.L., et al., Analysis of active islanding detection methods for
grid-connected microinverters for renewable energy processing. Applied
Energy, 2010. 87(11): p. 3591-3605.
[17] Doumbia, M.L., K. Agbossou, and T.K. Bose. Islanding protection
evaluation of inverter-based grid-connected hybrid renewable energy
system. in Electrical and Computer Engineering, 2004. Canadian
Conference on. 2004.
[18] Skocil, T., et al. Passive and active methods of islanding for PV systems.
in Power Electronics and Applications, 2009. EPE '09. 13th European
Conference on. 2009.
[19] Aljankawey, A.S., et al. Passive method-based islanding detection of
Renewable-based Distributed Generation: The issues. Electric Power
and Energy Conference (EPEC), 2010 IEEE 2010 25-27 Aug. 2010; 1-
8].
[20] Best, R., Phase-Locked Loops: Theory, Design, and Applications. 2nd
ed1993: McGraw-Hill Inc.
[21] Brennan, P.V., Phase-Locked Loops: Principles and Practice1996:
MacMillan Press Ltd.
[22] Guan-Chyun, H. and J.C. Hung, Phase-locked loop techniques. A survey.
Industrial Electronics, IEEE Transactions on, 1996. 43(6): p. 609-615.
[23] Ward Bower and M. Ropp., Evaluation of Islanding Detection Methods
for Utility-Interactive Inverters in Photovoltaic Systems, in SAND2002-
3591 Unlimited Release2002.
[24] Jang, S.I. and K.H. Kim. A new islanding detection algorithm for
distributed generations interconnected with utility networks. in
Developments in Power System Protection, 2004. Eighth IEE
International Conference on. 2004.
[25] Kobayashi, H., et al. Method for preventing islanding phenomenon on
utility grid with a number of small scale PV systems. in Photovoltaic
Specialists Conference, 1991., Conference Record of the Twenty Second
IEEE. 1991.
[26] Liserre, M., et al., An Anti-Islanding Method for Single-Phase Inverters
Based on a Grid Voltage Sensorless Control. Industrial Electronics,
IEEE Transactions on, 2006. 53(5): p. 1418-1426.
[27] Sung-Il, J. and K. Kwang-Ho, An islanding detection method for
distributed generations using voltage unbalance and total harmonic
distortion of current. Power Delivery, IEEE Transactions on, 2004.
19(2): p. 745-752.
[28] Kunte, R.S. and G. Wenzhong. Comparison and review of islanding
detection techniques for distributed energy resources. in Power
Symposium, 2008. NAPS '08. 40th North American. 2008.
[29] Lopes, L.A.C. and S. Huili, Performance assessment of active frequency
drifting islanding detection methods. Energy Conversion, IEEE
Transactions on, 2006. 21(1): p. 171-180.
[30] Gwon-jong, Y., et al. Boundary conditions of reactive-power-variation
method and active-frequency-drift method for islanding detection of
grid-connected photovoltaic inverters. in Photovoltaic Specialists
Conference, 2005. Conference Record of the Thirty-first IEEE. 2005.
[31] Liu, F., Y. Kang, and S. Duan. Analysis and optimization of active
frequency drift islanding detection method. in Applied Power Electronics
Conference, APEC 2007 - Twenty Second Annual IEEE. 2007.
[32] Youngseok Jung, Jaeho Choi, and G. Yu, A Novel Active Anti-islanding
Method for Grid-connected Photovoltaic Inverter. Journal of Power
Electronics, 2007. Vol. 7, No. 1 p. 64-71.
[33] Llaria, A., et al., Survey on microgrids: Unplanned islanding and related
inverter control techniques. Renewable Energy, 2010. 36(8): p. 2052-
2061.
[34] Wen-Yeau, C. A hybrid islanding detection method for distributed
synchronous generators. in Power Electronics Conference (IPEC), 2010
International. 2010.
[35] Jun, Y., C. Liuchen, and C. Diduch. A New Hybrid Anti-Islanding
Algorithm in Grid Connected Three-Phase Inverter System. in Power
Electronics Specialists Conference, 2006. PESC '06. 37th IEEE. 2006.
[36] Menon, V. and M.H. Nehrir, A Hybrid Islanding Detection Technique
Using Voltage Unbalance and Frequency Set Point. Power Systems,
IEEE Transactions on, 2007. 22(1): p. 442-448.
[37] Ghazi, R. and N. Lotfi. A new hybrid intelligent based approach to
islanding detection in distributed generation. in Universities Power
Engineering Conference (UPEC), 2010 45th International. 2010.
[38] Lei, D., et al. An Integrated Automatic Control System for Distributed
Generation Hierarchical Islanding. in Power System Technology, 2006.
PowerCon 2006. International Conference on. 2006.
[39] Mylène Robitaille. , et al., Islanding Detection Method for a Hybrid
Renewable Energy System. International Journal of Renewable Energy
Research, IJRER, 2011. Vol.1 , No.1, pp.41-53.
[40] IEA International Energy Agency, Bas Verhoeven, and K.N. B.V.,
Utility Aspects of Grid Connected Photovoltaic Power systems, in Task V
Report IEA PVPS T5-011998.
[41] Redfern, M.A., O. Usta, and G. Fielding, Protection against loss of
utility grid supply for a dispersed storage and generation unit. Power
Delivery, IEEE Transactions on, 1993. 8(3): p. 948-954.
[42] Wilsun, X., et al., A Power Line Signaling Based Technique for Anti-
Islanding Protection of Distributed Generators—Part I: Scheme
and Analysis. Power Delivery, IEEE Transactions on, 2007. 22(3): p.
1758-1766.
[43] Ropp, M.E., et al. Using power line carrier communications to prevent
islanding [of PV power systems]. in Photovoltaic Specialists
Conference, 2000. Conference Record of the Twenty-Eighth IEEE. 2000.
[44] Ropp, M., et al. Discussion of a Power Line Carrier Communications-
Based Anti-Islanding Scheme using a Commercial Automatic Meter
Reading System. in Photovoltaic Energy Conversion, Conference Record
of the 2006 IEEE 4th World Conference on. 2006.
[45] IEEE, IEEE Recommended Criteria for Terrestrial Photovoltaic Power
Systems, in ANSI/IEEE Std 928-19861986. p. 0_1.
[46] IEEE, IEEE Recommended Practice for Utility Interface of Residential
and Intermediate Photovoltaic (PV) Systems, in ANSI/IEEE Std 929-
19881987. p. 0_1.
[47] IEA International Energy Agency, et al., Risk Analysis of Islanding of
Photovoltaic Power Systems Within Low Voltage Distribution Networks.
Task V Report IEA PVPS T508: 2002, 2002.