The Ethics of Dissent: The Case of David Kelly

In this paper, we rely on the story of the late British weapons inspector David Kelly to illustrate how sensemaking can inform the study of the ethics of suppression of dissent. Using archival data, we reconstruct Dr. Kelly-s key responsibilities as a weapons inspector and government employee. We begin by clarifying the concept of dissent and how it is a useful organizational process. We identify the various ways that dissent has been discussed in the organizational literature and reconsider the process of sensemaking. We conclude that suppression of opinions that deviate from the majority is part of the identity maintenance of the sensemaking process. We illustrate the prevention of dissent in organizations consists of a set of unsatisfactory trade-offs.

Authors:

• A. Kayes
• D. Christopher Kayes

Keywords:

• ethics
• dissent
• suppression
• sensemaking

References:

[1] Ashforth, B. and V. Anand: 2003, ÔÇÿThe Normalization of Corruption in
Organizations-, Research in Organizational Behavior 25, 1-52.
[2] Clegg, S. R., D. Courpasson and N. Phillips: 2006, Power and
Organizations (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA).
[3] Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States
Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction: 2005, March 31, Report to
the President of the United States,
http://www.wmd.gov/report/wmd_report.pdf. Accessed 27 Sep 2007.
[4] Committee of Privy Counsellors: 2004, July 14, The Butler Review of
Intelligence on Weapons of Mass Destruction (The Stationery Office,
London), http://www.butlerreview.org.uk/report/. Accessed 27 Sep
2007.
[5] Director of National Intelligence, CIA: 2002, October, ÔÇÿIraq-s
Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction-, in National
Intelligence Estimate, http://www.fas.org/irp/cia/product/iraq-wmd.pdf.
Accessed 27 Sep 2007.
[6] Drumheller, T.: 2006, On the Brink (Carroll & Graf, New York).
[7] Dutton, J. E., L. S. J. Ashford, K. A., Lawrence and K. Miner-Rubino:
2002, ÔÇÿRed Light, Green Light: Making Sense of the Organizational
Context for Issue Selling-, Organization Science 13(4), 355-369.
[8] Eisenhardt, K. M. and M. E. Graebner: 2007, ÔÇÿTheory Building from
Cases: Opportunities and Challenges-, Academy of Management
Journal 50(1), 25-32.
[9] Festinger, L.: 1957, A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance (Row Peterson,
Evanston, IL).
[10] Frankena, W.: 1973, Ethics (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
[11] Goffman, E.: 1961, Asylums (Penguin, Harmondsworth, UK).
[12] Hamilton, H. L. (2011). Employee dissent in federal government
organizations. Corporate Communications, 16(3), 255-273.
[13] Hutton, J. B. E.: 2004, January 28, Investigation into the Circumstances
Surrounding the Death of Dr. David Kelly [the Hutton Inquiry] (The
Stationery Office, London), http://www.the-hutton-inquiry.org.uk.
Accessed 27 Sep 2007.
[14] Kerr, R., T. Wolfe, R. Donegan and A. Pappas: 2004, July 29,
Intelligence and Analysis on Iraq: Issues for the Intelligence Community
[The Kerr Report],
http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/news/20051013/kerr_report.pdf.Accesse
d 20 June 2008.
[15] Lang, P.: 2004, Summer, ÔÇÿDrinking the Kool-Aid-, Middle East Policy
XI(2), 39-60.
[16] Lee, T. W., T. R. Mitchell and C. J. Sablynski: 1999, ÔÇÿQualitative
Research in Organizational and Vocational Psychology, 1979-1999-,
Journal of Vocational Behavior 55(2), 161-187.
[17] Levine, D.: 2005, ÔÇÿThe corrupt organization?- Human Relations 58(6),
723-740.
[18] March, J. G., L. S. Sproull and M. Tamuz: 1991, ÔÇÿLearning from
Samples of One or Fewer-, Organization Science 2(1), 1-13.
[19] McLaughlin, J.: 2008, April 28, Lessons from the Search for Iraqi
Weapons of Mass Destruction. Presentation at The George Washington
University, Elliott School of International Affairs, Security Policy
Forum.
[20] Melton, H. K. and R. Wallace: 2009, The Official CIA Manual of
Trickery and Deception (Harper Collins, New York).
[21] Miller, R. B.: 1991, Casuistry and Modern Ethics (University of
Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
[22] Munchus, G. (2007). Managing the unwanted truth: A framework for
dissent strategy. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 20(6),
747-760.
[23] Noah, T.: 2005, May 31, ÔÇÿDeep Throat, Antihero: His Unmasking
Makes Everybody Look a Little Less Noble-, Slate.com,
http://www.slate.com/id/2119870/#. Accessed 20 June 2008.
[24] Nussbaum, M.: 1986, The Fragility of Goodness: Luck and Ethics in
Greek Tragedy (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK).
[25] Nyberg, D.: 1993, The Varnished Truth: Truth Telling and Deceiving in
Ordinary Life (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
[26] Orton, D. J.: 2000, ÔÇÿEnactment, Sensemaking and Decision Making:
Redesign Processes in the 1976 Reorganization of US Intelligence-,
Journal of Management Studies 37(2), 213-234.
[27] Pentland, B. T.: 1999, ÔÇÿBuilding Process Theory with Narrative: From
Description to Explanation-, Academy of Management Review 24, 711-
724.
[28] Pillar, P. R.: 2006, March/April, ÔÇÿIntelligence, Policy, and the War in
Iraq-, Foreign Affairs, http://www.foreignaffairs.org/
20060301faessay85202/paul-r-pillar/intelligence policy-and-the-war-iniraq.
html. Accessed 27 Sep 2007.
[29] Robin, D.: 2009, ÔÇÿToward an Applied Meaning for Ethics in Business-,
Journal of Business Ethics 89(1), 139-150.
[30] Robinson, M. D. and C. D. Ryff: 1999, ÔÇÿThe Role of Self-Deception in
Perceptions of Past, Present and Future Happiness-, Personality and
Social Psychology Bulletin 25(5), 596-608.
[31] Shahainpoor, N., and Matt, B. F. (2007). The power of one: Dissent and
organizational life.
[32] Journal of Business Ethics, 74. 1 37-48.
[33] Smith, D., and D. Elliot (eds.): 2006, Key Readings in Crisis
Management (Routledge, London).
[34] UK Joint Intelligence Committee: 2002, September, Iraq-s Weapons of
Mass Destruction: The Assessment of the British Government (The
Stationery Office, London),
http://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/kfile/iraqdossier.pdf. Accessed 27 Sep
2007.
[35] Warren, B. and D. Rosenthal: 2006, ÔÇÿTeaching Business Ethics - Is It a
Lost Cause?- International Journal of Management 23(3), 679-698.
[36] Weick, K. E.: 1995, Sensemaking in Organizations (Sage, Newbury
Park, CA).
[37] Weick, K. E.: 2007, ÔÇÿThe Generative Properties of Richness-, Academy
of Management Journ