Integration and Selectivity in Open Innovation:An Empirical Analysis in SMEs

The company-s ability to draw on a range of external sources to meet their needs for innovation, has been termed 'open innovation' (OI). Very few empirical analyses have been conducted on Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) to the extent that they describe and understand the characteristics and implications of this new paradigm. The study's objective is to identify and characterize different modes of OI, (considering innovation process phases and the variety and breadth of the collaboration), determinants, barriers and motivations in SMEs. Therefore a survey was carried out among Italian manufacturing firms and a database of 105 companies was obtained. With regard to data elaboration, a factorial and cluster analysis has been conducted and three different OI modes have emerged: selective low open, unselective open upstream, and mid- partners integrated open. The different behaviours of the three clusters in terms of determinants factors, performance, firm-s technology intensity, barriers and motivations have been analyzed and discussed.

Authors:

• Chiara Verbano
• Maria Crema
• Karen Venturini

Keywords:

• Open innovation
• R&D management
• SMEs.

References:

[1] Ahuja G. (2000). "Collaboration networks, structural holes, and
innovation: a longitudinal study", Administrative Science Quarterly, V.
45, (3): 425-455.
[2] Lauren K., Salter A. (2006). "Open for innovation: the role of openness
in explaining innovation performance among U.K. manufacturing
firms", Strategic Management Journal, V. 27, 131-150.
[3] Dahlander L., Gann D. (2007). "How open is innovation?", Summer
Conference 2007 on Appropriability, Proximity, Routines and
Innovation Copenhagen, CBS, Denmark, June 18 - 20.
[4] Lichtenthaler U. (2008(a)). "Open innovation in practice: an analysis of
strategic approaches to technology transactions", IEEE transactions on
engineering management, V. 55, (1): 148-157.
[5] Gassman, O., Enkel, E. (2004). "Towards a Theory of Open Innovation:
Three Core Process Archetypes," in Proceedings of the R&D
Management Conference, Lisbon, Portugal, July 6-9
[6] Kolk, A., P├╝├╝mann, K. (2008), "Co-development of open innovation
strategy and dynamic capabilities as a source of corporate growth",
Working Papers in Economics n.173, Tallinn University of Technology
(TUTWPE), s. 73-83. (Available on line at
http://ideas.repec.org/p/ttu/wpaper/173.html)
[7] Lichtenthaler U. (2009). "Outbound open innovation and its effect on
firm performance: examining environmental influences", R&D
Management, V. 39, (4): 317-330.
[8] Lazzarotti V., Manzini R. e Pellegrini L. (2010). "Open innovation
models adepted in pratice: an extensive study in Italy", Measuring
Business Excellence, V. 14, (4): 11-23.
[9] Knudsen, M. P. and T. B. Mortensen (2011). "Some Immediate - but
Negative - Effects of Openness on Product Development Performance."
Technovation 31: 54-64.
[10] Lee, S., Park, G., Yoon, B. and Park, J. (2010) Open innovation in
SMEs - an intermediated network model. Research Policy, 29, 290-
300.
[11] Narula, R. (2004) R&D collaboration by SMEs: new opportunities and
limitations in the face of globalization. Technovation, 25: 153-161.
[12] Lichtenthaler U., Ernst H. (2009). "Opening up the innovation process:
the role of technology aggressiveness", R&D Management, V. 39, (1):
38-54.
[13] Van de Vrande, V., de Jong, J.P.J., Vanhaverbeke, W. and de
Rochemont, M. (2009) Open innovation in SMEs: trends, motives and
management challenges. Technovation, 29, 423-437.
[14] Chesbrough H. (2003). Open innovation: The new imperative for
creating and profiting from technology, Boston: Havard Business
School Press.
[15] Huizingh E.K.R.E. (2011), "Open innovation: State of art and future
perspectives", Technovation, V. 31, (1): 2-9.
[16] Dahlander L., Gann D. (2010), "How open is innovation?", Research
Policy, V. 39: 699-709.
[17] Laursen K. e Salter A. (2004). "Searching high and low: what type of
firms use universities as a source of innovation?", Research Policy, V.
33, (8): 1201-1215
[18] Pisano G.P. e Verganti R. (2008). "Which kind of collaboration is right
for you?", Harvard Business Review, December, 1-9.
[19] Enkel E., Gassmann O., Chesbrough H. (2009). "Open R&D e Open
Innovation: exploring the phenomenon", R&D Management, V. 39, (4):
311-316.
[20] Von Hippel E. (1988). The Sources of Innovation, Oxford University
Press, New York.
[21] Lundvall, B. A. (ed.)(1992), National Systems of innovation: towards a
theory of innovation and interactive learning, London: Pinter.
[22] Elmquist M., Fredberg T., Ollila S. (2009). "Exploring the field of open
innovation", European Journal of Innovation Management, V. 12, (3):
326-345.
[23] Brown, S.L., K.M. Eisenhardt (1995). "Product development: Past
research, present findings, and future directions", Acad. Management
Rev., V.20: 343-378
[24] Szulanski, G. (1996). "Exploring internal stickiness: Impediments to the
transfer of best practice within the firm", Strategic Management
Review, 17(1): 27-43.
[25] Lazzarotti V., Manzini R. (2009). "Different modes of open innovation:
a theoretical framework and an empirical study", International Journal
of Innovation Management , V. 13, (4): 615-636.
[26] Keupp M.M., Gassman O. (2009). "Determinants and archetype users of
open innovation", R&D Management, V. 39, (4): 331-341.
[27] Nelson R.R., Winter S. (1982). An Evolutionary Theory of Economic
Change, Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
[28] Levinthal DA, March JG. (1993). "The myopia of learning", Strategic
Management Journal, Winter Special Issue, V. 14: 95-112
[29] Cohen W.M., Levinthal D.A. (1990). "Absorptive capacity: a new
perspective on learning and innovation", Administrative Science
Quarterly, V. 35, (1): 128-152.
[30] Klevorick AK, Levin RC, Nelson RR, Winter SG, "On the sources and
significance of interindustry differences in technological opportunities",
Research Policy, vol. 24(2), 1995, pp. 185-205.
[31] Gassmann O., Enkel E., Chesbrough H. (2010). "The future of open
innovation", R&D Management, V. 40, (3): 213-221.
[32] Gassmann O., Enkel E. (2010). "Creative innovation: exploring the case
of cross-industry innovation", R&D Management, V. 40, (3): 256-270.
[33] Fortuin and Omta, (2008), "Innovation drivers and barriers in food
processing", British Food Journal, Vol.111 (8): 839-851.
[34] Gassmann O., (2006), "Opening up the innovation process: towards an
agenda", R&D Management, V. 36, (3): 223-228.
[35] Anderson P., Tushman, M.L. (1990). "Technological discontinuities and
dominant designs: A cyclical model of technological change"
Administrative Science Quarterly, V.35, (4): 604-633.
[36] Mazzoleni R. e Nelson R.R. (1998). "The benefits and costs of strong
patent protection: a contribution to the current debate", Research Policy,
V. 27, 273-284.
[37] Arora A., Fosfuri A. e Gambardella A. (2001). Markets for Technology:
the Economics of Innovation and Corporate Strategy, MIT Press,
Cambridge.
[38] Herstad S.J., Bloch C., Ebersberger B., Van de Velde E. (2008). "Open
innovation and globalisation: Theory, evidence and implications",
Vision era net shared knowledge bases for sustainable innovation
policies. Oslo: NIFU STEP.
[39] Sousa M. (2008). "Open innovation models and the role of knowledge
brokers", Inside knowledge, V. 11, (6): 18-22.
[40] Schilling M.A. (2010). Strategic management of technological
innovation, 3rd edition, McGraw-Hill, New York.
[41] Sobrero M. (1999). La gestione dell-innovazione: strategia,
organizzazione e tecniche operative, Carrocci editore.
[42] Chesbrough H. (2006). Open business models. How to thrive in the new
innovation landscape, Havard Business School Press.
[43] Rothaermel, Frank T. & Deeds, David L. (2006). "Alliance type,
alliance experience and alliance management capability in high-
technology ventures", Journal of Business Venturing, Elsevier, vol.
21(4), pages 429-460, July.
[44] Van der Meer H. (2007). "Open Innovation - The Dutch Treat:
Challenges in Thinking in Business Models", Creativity and innovation
management, V. 16, (2): 192-202.
[45] Tidd J., Bessant J. (2009). Managing innovation, 4th edition,Wiley,
Chichester
[46] Dodgson M., Gann D., Salter A. (2006). "The role of technology in the
shift towards open innovation: the case of Procter & Gamble", R&D
Management, V. 36, (3): 333-346.
[47] Hrastinski S., Kviselius N.Z. (2010). "A review of technologies for open
innovation: characteristics and future trends", Proceedings of the 43rd
Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences - 2010.
[48] Chiaroni D., Chiesa V., Frattini F. (2010). "Unravelling the process
from closed to open innovation: evidence from mature, asset-intensive
industries", R&D Management, V. 40, (3): 222-245.
[49] Parida V. (2009). "Challenges in open innovation practices for
industries", The 3rd nordic innovation research conference - NIR -
2008 - IEM Arctic workshop, 27-40.
[50] Lichtenthaler U. (2008 (b)). "Integrated roadmaps for open innovation",
Research Technology Management, V. 51, (3): 45-49.
[51] Chesbrough H., Vanhaverbeke W., West J. (2006). Open innovation:
researching a new paradigm, Oxford University Press.
[52] Nobellius D. (2004). "Towards the sixth generation of R&D
management", International Journal of Project Management, V. 22, 369-
375.
[53] Chesbrough H. e Crowther A.K. (2006). "Beyond high tech: early
adopters of open innovation in other industries", R&D Management, V.
36, (3): 229-236.
[54] Arora A. e Gambardella A. (1994). "The changing technology of
technological change: General and abstract knowledge and the division
of innovative labour", Res. Policy, V. 23: 523-532.
[55] Bröring S., Herzog P. (2008). "Organising new business development:
open innovation at Degussa", European Journal of Innovation
Management, V. 11, (3): 330-348.
[56] Teece D.J. (1998). "Capturing value from knowledge assets: the new
economy, markets for know-how, and intangible assets", California
Management Review, V. 40, (3): 55-79.
[57] Bianchi, M., Cavaliere, A., Chiaroni, D., Frattini, F., Chiesa, V. (2011) .
"Organisational modes for open innovation in the bio-pharmaceutical
industry: an exploratory analysis" Technovation, V. 31, (1): 22-33.
[58] Keupp M.M. e Gassmann O. (2007). "The competitive advantage of
early and rapidly internationalizing SMEs in the biotechnology industry:
a knowledge based view", Journal of World Business, Special Issue: The
Early and Rapid Internationalisation of the Firm, V. 42, (3): 350-366.
[59] Venturini K., Verbano C., Salmaso L. (2010), "Open Innovation in
Firms Located in the Republic of San Marino", Conference on Research
In Entrepreneurship And Small Business Proceedings CD, Maastricht,
The Netherlands, November 18-19.
[60] Asakawa K., Nakamura H., Sawada N. (2010). "Firms- open innovation
policies, laboratories, and laboratories- R&D performance", R&D
Management, V. 40, (2): 109-123.
[61] Hamel, G. (1991). Competition for Competence and Inter-Partner
Learning Within International Strategic Alliances. Strategic
Management Journal 12: 83-103
[62] Quinn J. and Hilmer F., (1994), Strategic outsourcing, Sloan
Management Review Summer (1994), pp. 43-55.
[63] Calantone, R.J., Stanko, M.A. (2007), "Drivers of outsourced
innovation: an exploratory study", The Journal of Product Innovation
Management, Vol. 24 pp.230-41.
[64] Grönlund J., Sjödin D.R., Frishammar J. (2010). "Open innovation and
the stage-gate process: a revised model for new product development",
California Management Review, V. 52, (3): 106-131.
[65] Leonard-Barton D. (1995). Well Springs of Knowledge: Building and
Sustaining the Source of Innovation, Harvard Business School Press,
Boston, MA.
[66] Christensen J.F., Olesen M.H., Kjær J.S. (2005). "The industrial
dynamics of open innovationÔÇöevidence from the transformation of
consumer electronics", Research Policy, V. 34, (10): 1599-1549.
[67] Igartua J.I., Garrig├│s J.A., and Hervas-Oliver J.L. (2010). "How
innovation management techniques support an open innovation
strategy", Research Technology Management, V. 53, (3): 41-52
[68] Chesbrough H. (2002). "Making sense of corporate venture capital",
Harvard Business Review, vol. 80, 2002, pp. 4-11.
[69] Keil T. (2004). "Building external corporate venturing capability:
Initial conditions, learning processes, and knowledge management",
Journal of Management Studies, V. 41, (5): 799-825.
[70] Granstrand O. (2000). The Economics and Management of Intellectual
Property: towards Intellectual Capitalism, Edward Elgar Publishing,
Northampton.
[71] Rosenberg N. (1990). "Why do firms do basic research (with their own
money)?", Research Policy, V. 19, 165-174.
[72] De Jong, J.P.J., Vanhaverbeke W., Kalvet T., Chesbrough H. (2008).
"Policies for Open Innovation: Theory, Framework and Cases", Vision
era net shared knowledge bases for sustainable innovation policies, pp.
14-48, 115-123.
[73] Smith K. (2000). "Innovation as a Systemic Phenomenon: Rethinking
the Role of Policy", Enterprise and Innovation Management Studies,
vol..1 (1): 73-102
[74] Cassiman, B., Veugelers, R., 2006. In search of complementarity in
innovation strategy: Internal R&D and external knowledge acquisition.
Management Science 52 (1), pp.68-82.
[75] Davis J.L., Harrison S.S. (2001). Edison in the Boardroom: how
Leading Companies Realize Value from their Intellectual Assets, New
York: John Wiley & Sons.
[76] Lin B.-W., Chen C.-J. e Wu H.-L. (2006). "Patent portfolio diversity,
technology strategy, and firm value", IEEE Transactions on Engineering
Management, V. 53, (1): 17-26
[77] Lichtenthaler U. (2005). "External commercialization of knowledge:
review and research agenda", International Journal of Management
Reviews, V. 7, (4): 231-255.
[78] Miles R. e Snow C. (1978). Organizational Strategy, Structure and
Process, New York: McGraw-Hill.
[79] Brockhoff K., Pearson A. (1992) "Technical and marketing
aggressiveness and the effectiveness of research and development",
IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, V. 39, (4): 318-324.
[80] Lettl C., Herstatt C. e Gemuenden H. G. (2006). "Users- contributions
to radical innovation: Evidence from four cases in the field of medical
equipment technology", R&D Manage, V. 36, (3): 251-272.
[81] Perrons R. K., Richards M. G. e Platts K. (2005). "What the hare can
teach the tortoise about make-buy strategies for radical innovations",
Management Decision, V. 43, (5): 670-690.
[82] Rivette K.G. e Kline D. (2000). Rembrandts in the Attic: unlocking the
Hidden Value of Patents, Harvard Business School Press, Boston.
[83] Cesaroni F. (2004 )."Technological outsourcing and product
diversification: Do markets for technology affect firms- strategies?",
Research. Policy, V. 33, 1547-1564.
[84] Hagedoorn J. (1993). "Understanding the rationale of strategic
technology partnering: interorganisational modes of cooperation and
sectoral differences", Strategic Management Journal, V. 14, pp. 371-
385.
[85] Blumentritt T., Danis W.M. (2006). "Business strategy types and
innovative practices", Journal of Managerial Issues, V. 18, (2): 274-291.
[86] OECD (organisation for economic co-operation and development
statistical office of the european communities) (2005), Oslo manual:
guidelines for collecting and interpreting innovation data, Parigi:
OECD/European Communities.
[87] Eurostat (2009). "High-technology and knowledge based services
aggregations based on NACE Rev.2",
(http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/cache/ITY_SDDS/Annexes/htec_esms
_an3.pdf).
[88] Chesbrough H.(2003b). "The era of open innovation", Sloan
management review, V. 44, (3): 35-41.
[89] Aylen J. (2010). "Open versus closed innovation: development of the
wide strip mill for steel in the United States during the 1920s", R&D
Management, V. 40, (1): 67-80.
[90] Fine C.H. (1998). Clockspeed: Winning Industry Control in the Age of
Temporary Advantage, Reading, MA: Perseus Books.