Developing Marketing Strategy in Nonmetallic Mineral Industry at the Business Level

This study extends research on the relationship between marketing strategy and market segmentation by investigating on market segments in the cement industry. Competitive strength and rivals distance from the factory were used as business environment. A three segment (positive, neutral or indifferent and zero zones) were identified as strategic segments. For each segment a marketing strategy (aggressive, defensive and decline) were developed. This study employed data from cement industry to fulfill two objectives, the first is to give a framework to the segmentation of cement industry and the second is developing marketing strategy with varying competitive strength. Fifty six questionnaires containing close-and open-ended questions were collected and analyzed. Results supported the theory that segments tend to be more aggressive than defensive when competitive strength increases. It is concluded that high strength segments follow total market coverage, concentric diversification and frontal attack to their competitors. With decreased competitive strength, Business tends to follow multi-market strategy, product modification/improvement and flank attack to direct competitors for this kind of segments. Segments with weak competitive strength followed focus strategy and decline strategy.

Authors:

• Nader Gharibnavaz
• Naser Gharibnavaz

Keywords:

• Marketing strategy
• Competitive strength
• Market Segmentation

References:

[1] Abhay, S. (1991). 'An Inter-industry empirical study investigating The
Relationship between Environment and marketing strategy in Service'
PH.D. Diss, The university of oklahoma,
[2] Bettis A. William K. Hall(1981), Strategic Portfolio Management in
the Multi business Firm, California Management Review,
Fall(1981)VOL. XXIV / NO. 1
[3] Birger Wernerfelt and Cynthia A. Montgomery (1986), 'What Is an
Attractive Industry?' Management Science, Vol. 32, No. 10, (Oct.,
1986), pp. 1223-1230
[4] Bloom, P. & P. Kotler (1975). 'Strategies for High Market Share
Companies' Harvard Business Review, vol.53,No 6,November-
December,pp63-72
[5] Burke C.(1984). 'Strategic Choice and Marketing Managers: An
Examination of Business-Level Marketing' Journal of Marketing
Research, Vol. 21, No. 4, (Nov., 1984), pp. 345-359
[6] Buzzell R.D. Gale B.T. and Sultan R.G.M.(1975). 'Market Share ,A key
to profitability' Harvard Business Review, vol.53,No 1,January-February
,pp63-72
[7] Brush, C. G., & Vanderwerf, P. A. (1992). 'A comparison of methods
and sources of obtaining estimates of new venture performance'. Journal
of Business Venturing, 7(2), 157T170.
[8] Bruggen, H. B.Wierenga (2000) 'Broadening the perspective on
marketing decision models' Research in Marketing, 17(2000)159-168
[9] Chakravarthy, B. S. (1986). Measuring strategic performance. Strategic
Management Journal, 7(5), 437T458.
[10] Chandler, G. N., & Hanks, S. H. (1993). 'Measuring the performance of
emerging businesses: Avalidation study'. Journal of Business Venturing,
8(5), 391T408.
[11] Ghemawat P.(2002). 'Competition and Business Strategy in Historical
Perspective' The Business History Review, Vol. 76, No. 1, (Spring,
2002), pp. 37-74
[12] Churchill, A. (1979). 'A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of
Marketing Constructs' Journal of Marketing Research Vol. XVI
(February 1979). 64-73
[13] Cook J. (1983). 'Marketing Strategy and Differential Advantage' Journal
of Marketing, Vol.47 (spring 1983), 68-75
[14] Day, G. (1977). 'Diagnosing the Product Portfolio' Journal of Marketing,
41 April, 29-38
[15] Dougal, P. & B. Robinson, (1990). 'New Venture Strategies: An
Emprical Identification of Eight Archetypes of Competitive Strategies
for Entry" Strategic Management Journal, 11 (October), 447-67
[16] Fornell, C. and B. Wernerfelt (1987). 'Defensive Marketing Strategy by
Customer Complaint Management: A Theoretical Analysis' Journal of
Marketing Research Vol. XXIV (November 1987), 337-46
[17] Foster, D. (1970). 'Product-Market Strategy' Long Range Planning,
vol.3,March,pp 70-77
[18] Greenly, E. (1989). 'An Understanding of Marketing Strategy' European
Journal of Marketing,23(8),pp 45-58
[19] Gupta K. Anil, Govindarajan(1984), Business Unit Strategy, Managerial
Characteristics, and Business Unit Effectiveness at Strategy
Implementation, Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 27, No1. 25-41
[20] Hofer and Schendel (1978), Strategy Formulation Analytical Concept:
West Publishing Company.p245
[21] Hamermesh R.(1986),' Making planning strategic' Harvard Business
Review July-August.
[22] Homburg, C. P. Workman Jr., & Harley Krohmer (1999) 'Marketing's
Influence Within the firm' Journal of Marketing , Vol. 63 (April 1999),
1-17
[23] Kotler P.(2006). Marketing Management, Pearson Education, Eleventh
Edition, p309
[24] Lilien G. P, Kotler, K. Sridhar (1992) Marketing Models, Prentice Hall p
552,(Reprinted in New Delhi)
[25] Mascarenhas, B. Arun Kumaraswamy, Diana Day, Alok Baveja (2002).
'Five Strategies for Rapid Firm Growth and How to Implement Them'
Managerial and Decision Economics, Vol. 23, No. 4/5, (Jun. - Aug.,
2002), pp. 317-330
[26] Mavondo, T.(1999). 'Environment and strategy as antecedents for
marketing effectiveness and organizational performance' Journal of
Strategic Marketing 7 237-250
[27] McDonald, Malcolm(1995),Marketing Plans How to Prepare Them How
to Use Them, Third Edition, Butterworth Heinemann
[28] Mckee, O. p Vardarjan (1989). 'Strategic Adaptability and firm
Performance: A Market- Contingent perspective' Journal of Marketing
Vol. 53(July 1989), 21-35
[29] McDaniel, W.& S. Kolari (1987). 'Marketing Strategy Implication of
The Miles and Snow Strategic Typology' Journal of Marketing , vol
41 , October, pp 19 - 30
[30] Menon, A. G. Bharadwaj, T. Adidam, & Steven W. Edison (1999).
Antecedents and Consequences of Marketing Strategy Making: A Modei
and a Test, Journal of Marketing Vol. 63 (April 1999), 18-40
[31] Menon, A.& Anil Menon (1997). 'Enviropreneurial Marketing
Strategy: The Emergence of Corporate Environmentalism as Market
Strategy' Journal of Marketing Vol. 61 (January 1997), 51-67
[32] Neill Stern and Gregory M. Rose(2006), The effect of strategic
complexity on marketing strategy andorganizational performance,
Journal of Business Research 59 (2006) 1 - 10
[33] Park, M. J. Mason,(1990). 'Toward An Integration Model of the
Determinants of Business Level Strategic Planning Perspective'
Research in Marketing, Vol. 10,pp. 157-202
[34] Saxby, L. & C. Abercrombie (1995). 'Selecting Marketing Strategy
Through Environmental analysis' The Journal of Marketing
Management, Spring ,summer , Volume 5 , Issue 1 , pp 16 - 20
[35] Sinkula JM. Market information processing and organizational
learning. J Mark 1994;58(1):35 -45.
[36] Slater, F. and Eric M. Olson (2001) 'Marketing's Contribution to the
Implementation of Business Strategy: An Empirical Analysis' Strategic
Management Journal, Vol. 22, No. 11, (Nov., 2001), pp. 1055-1067
[37] Spohn, D. (2004) 'Evaluating Market Attractiveness - A New Venture
Perspective' Ph.D. diss., Gallen University.
[38] Stern, N. & G. Rose (2006). 'The effect of strategic complexity on
marketing strategy and organizational performance' Journal of Business
Research 59 (2006) 1-10
[39] Sullivan O. & V. Abela (2007). 'Marketing Performance Measurement
Ability and Firm Performance' Journal of Marketing Vol. 71 (April
2007), 79-93
[40] Subhash, C. (1993). 'Marketing planning & Strategy' 4th edition, south
Western Publishing, pp. 390-515
[41] Venkatraman, N., & Ramanujam, V. (1986). 'Measurement of business
performance in strategy research: A comparison of approaches'.
Academy of Management Review, 11(4), 801T814.
[42] Walters, P. and S. Samiee (2003). 'Executive Insights: Marketing
Strategy in Emerging Markets, The Case of China' Journal of
International Marketing Vol. 11, No. 1, 2003, pp. 97-106
[43] Wissema, J. H. Pol, H. M. Messer (1980), 'Strategic Management
Archetypes, Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 1, No. 1, (Jan. - Mar.,
1980), pp. 37-47
[44] Wilemon, S. (1996). 'A Typology of Marketing Strategy Behaviors' The
Journal of Marketing Management, FalVWUJter1996
[45] Wind, Y.& S. Robertson (1983). 'Marketing Strategy: New Direction for
Theory and Research' Journal of Marketing, vol.47,Spring,pp 12-25
[46] Woo, C. and A. Cooper (1981). 'Strategies of Effective Low Share
Business' Strategic Management Journal, vol. 2,No 3,July-
September,pp301-318
[47] Xin, K. R., & Pearce, J. L. (1996). Guanxi: 'Connections as substitutes
for formal institutional support'. Academy of Management Journal,
39(6), 1641T1658.
[48] **Babai and Sherafat are Iranian researchers and Consultant in Cement
industry, their publication is in native language, so as the conference
language is English, we were unable to give persian references