Detecting Earnings Management via Statistical and Neural Network Techniques

Predicting earnings management is vital for the capital market participants, financial analysts and managers. The aim of this research is attempting to respond to this query: Is there a significant difference between the regression model and neural networks’ models in predicting earnings management, and which one leads to a superior prediction of it? In approaching this question, a Linear Regression (LR) model was compared with two neural networks including Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP), and Generalized Regression Neural Network (GRNN). The population of this study includes 94 listed companies in Tehran Stock Exchange (TSE) market from 2003 to 2011. After the results of all models were acquired, ANOVA was exerted to test the hypotheses. In general, the summary of statistical results showed that the precision of GRNN did not exhibit a significant difference in comparison with MLP. In addition, the mean square error of the MLP and GRNN showed a significant difference with the multi variable LR model. These findings support the notion of nonlinear behavior of the earnings management. Therefore, it is more appropriate for capital market participants to analyze earnings management based upon neural networks techniques, and not to adopt linear regression models.

Authors:

• Mohammad Namazi
• Mohammad Sadeghzadeh Maharluie

Keywords:

• Earnings management
• generalized regression neural networks
• linear regression
• multi-layer perceptron
• Tehran stock exchange.

References:

[1] Vladu A. B. and D. D. Cuzdrioreanb (2014). “Detecting earnings
management: Insights from the last decade leading journals published
research” Procedia Economics and Finance, Vol. 15, pp. 695-703.
[2] Graham, J. R., Raedy J. S., and D. A. Shackelford, (2012). “Research in
accounting for income taxes”, Journal of Accounting and Economics,
Vol. 53, pp. 412-434.
[3] Jansen, I. P.; Ramnath, S. and T. L. Yohn (2012) “A Diagnostic for
Earnings Management Using Changes in Asset Turnover and Profit
Margin.” Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol. 29, No. 1, pp. 221–
251.
[4] Capkun, V. (2011). “Book Review.” The International Journal of
Accounting, Vol. 46, No. 2, pp. 236-237.
[5] Wróblewski D., Jarne, José I. and S. Callao (2014). “The Development
of Earnings Management Research: A Review of Literature from Three
Different Perspectives” Theoretical Journal of Accounting (Zeszyty
Teoretyczne Rachunkowości), Vol. 79, pp. 135-177.
[6] Höglund, H. (2012). “Detecting Earnings Management with Neural
Networks.” Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 39, pp. 9564-9570.
[7] Höglund, H. (2013). “Fuzzy Linear Regression-Based Detection of
Earnings Management.” Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 40, pp.
6166-6172.
[8] DeTienne, K. B., DeTienne, D. H., and S. A. Joshi (2003). “Neural
Networks as Statistical Tools for Business Researchers” Organizational
Research Methods, Vol. 6(2), pp. 236–265.
[9] Tsai C. F. and Y. J. Chiou (2009). “Earnings Management Prediction: A
Pilot Study of Combining Neural Networks and Decision Trees.” Expert
Systems with Applications, Vol. 36, pp. 7183–7191.
[10] Dastgir, M. and A. Nazemi (2006). “Earnings Management: Reconciling
the Views of Accounting Academics, Practitioners, and Regulators:
Review of Iranian Studies” Journal Of Accounting Knowledge and
Study. Vol. 11, pp. 12-18.
[11] Ronen, J. and V. Yaari (2008) Earnings Management: Emerging Insights
in Theory, Practice, and Research, Springer, the USA.
[12] Scott, William R. (2009). Financial Accounting Theory. Fifth Edition.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
[13] Hribar, P., and D. W. Collins (2002). "Errors in Estimating Accruals:
Implications for Empirical Research." Journal of Accounting research
40(1), pp. 105-134.
[14] Healy, P. M. and J. M. Wahlen (1999). “A Review of the Earning
Management Literature and Its Implications for Standard Setting.”
Accounting Horizons, Vol. 13, PP. 365-383. [15] Bergstresser, D. and T. Philipponb (2006). “CEO Incentives and
Earnings Management.” Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 80, pp.
511–529.
[16] Namazi M. and E. Khansalar (2011). “An Investigation of The Income
Smoothing Behavior of Growth and Value Firms (Case Study: Tehran
Stock Exchange Market).” International Business Research, Vol. 4, No.
4, pp. 84-93.
[17] Denton, J. W. (1995). “How Good are Neural Networks for Causal
Forecasting?” Journal of Business Forecasting Methods and Systems,
Vol. 14(2), pp. 17–20.
[18] Warner, B.; and M. Misra (1996). “Understanding Neural Networks as
Statistical Tools” The American Statistician, Vol. 50(4), pp. 284–293.
[19] Marquez, L., Hill, T., Worthley, R., and W. Remus, (1992). Neural
network models as an alternative to regression.In R. Trippe & E. Turban
(Eds.), Neural Networks in Finance and investing (pp. 435–449).
Chicago: Probus.
[20] Namazi M, Shokrolahi A, and M. Sadeghzadeh Maharluie. (2014).
"Ranking Relative Importance of Various Determinants of the Free Cash
Flow Risk: A Neural Network Approach" the 4th African Accounting &
Finance Association Conference, South Africa, Cape Town, September
3-5.
[21] Rees, Lynn L., Gill, Susan and Richard Gore (1996). “An Investigation
of Asset Write-Downs and Concurrent Abnormal Accruals” Journal of
Accounting Research, Vol. 34, pp. 157-169.
[22] Ball R. and L. Shivakumar (2006). “The Role of Accruals in
Asymmetrically Timely Gain and Loss Recognition.” Journal of
Accounting Research, Vol. 44, No. 2, pp. 207-242.
[23] Aaker, H. and F. Gjesdal (2007). “Detecting True Earnings Management
and Evaluating Discretionary Accrual Models” International
Conference, Handelshögskolan vid Göreborgs University.
[24] Kouki, M.; Elkhaldi A.; Atri, Hanen; and S. Souid (2011). “Does
Corporate Governance Constrain Earnings Management? Evidence from
U.S. Firms” European Journal of Economics, Finance and
Administrative Sciences, Vol. 35, pp. 58-71.
[25] Menhaj, M. B. (2010). Introductory to Neural Networks, Seventh
Edition, Tehran, Amirkabir University of Technology.
[26] Duch, Wlodzislaw and Norbert Jankowski (1999). “Survey of Neural
Transfer Function”, Neural Computing Surveys, Vol. 2, pp. 163-212.
[27] Namazi, M. and M. M. Kiamehr (2007). “Predicting Daily Stock
Returns of Companies Listed in Tehran Stock Exchange Using Artificial
Neural Networks”. Journal of Financial Research, Tehran University,
Vol. 24, pp. 115-134.
[28] Moshiri, S. and H. Morovat (2005). “Predicting Tehran Stock Returns
Index by using Linear and Nonlinear Models” Trade Studies Quarterly,
Vol. 41, pp. 245-276.
[29] Dai, J.; Liu, X; Zhang, S.; Zhang, H.; Xu, Q.; Chen, W. and X. Zheng
(2010). “Continuous Neural Decoding Method Based on General
Regression Neural Network” International Journal of Digital Content
Technology and its Applications, Volume 4, Number 8, pp. 216-221.
[30] Zhang, G., Patuwo, B. E., and M. Y. Hu, (1998). “Forecasting with
Artificial Neural Networks: The State of the Art” International Journal
of Forecasting, Vol. 14(1), pp. 35–62.
[31] Hudson Beale, Mark; Hagan Martin T. and Howard B. Demuth (2012).
Neural Network Toolbox™ User’s Guide, The MathWorks, Inc.
[32] Hejazi, R; Mohammadi, S; Aslani, Z. and M. Aghajani (2012).
“Earnings Management Prediction Using Neural Networks and Decision
Tree in TSE”. Iranian Accounting and Auditing Review, Vol. 19 (2), pp.
31-46.