Gammarus:Asellus Ratio as an Index of Organic Pollution – (A Case Study in Markeaton, Kedleston Hall, and Allestree Park Lakes Derby) UK

Macro invertebrates have been used to monitor
organic pollution in rivers and streams. Several biotic indices based
on macro invertebrates have been developed over the years including
the Biological Monitoring Working Party (BMWP). A new biotic
index, the Gammarus:Asellus ratio has been recently proposed as an
index of organic pollution. This study tested the validity of the
Gammarus:Asellus ratio as an index of organic pollution, by
examining the relationship between the Gammarus:Asellus ratio and
physical chemical parameters, and other biotic indices such as
BMWP and, Average Score Per Taxon (ASPT) from lakes and
streams at Markeaton Park, Allestree Park and Kedleston Hall,
Derbyshire. Macro invertebrates were sampled using the standard
five minute kick sampling techniques physical and chemical
environmental variables were obtained based on standard sampling
techniques. Eighteen sites were sampled, six sites from Markeaton
Park (three sites across the stream and three sites across the lake). Six
sites each were also sampled from Allestree Park and Kedleston Hall
lakes. The Gammarus:Asellus ratio showed an opposite significant
positive correlations with parameters indicative of organic pollution
such as the level of nitrates, phosphates, and calcium and also
revealed a negatively significant correlations with other biotic indices
(BMWP/ASPT). The BMWP score correlated positively significantly
with some water quality parameters such as dissolved oxygen and
flow rate, but revealed no correlations with other chemical
environmental variables. The BMWP score was significantly higher
in the stream than the lake in Markeaton Park, also The ASPT scores
appear to be significantly higher in the upper Lakes than the middle
and lower lakes. This study has further strengthened the use of
BMWP/ASPT score as an index of organic pollution. But additional
application is required to validate the use of Gammarus:Asellus as a
rapid bio monitoring tool.

• U. Bawa

• Asellus
• Biotic index
• Gammarus
• Organic pollution
• Macro invertebrate.

[1] Metcalfe, J.L., “Biological water quality assessment of running waters
based on macroinvertebrate communities: history and present status in
Europe,” Environmental Pollution, vol. 60, no. 1, pp.101-139, 1989.
[2] Mason, C.F., Biology of freshwater pollution, 4th ed. Sesses: Perason
Education limited, 2002,
[3] Camargo, J.A.,”Macrobenthic surveys as a valuable tool for assessing
freshwater quality in the Iberian Peninsula,” Environmental Monitoring
and assessment, vol. 24, no.1, pp.71-90, 1993.
[4] Rosenberg, D.M., Resh, V.H.), Freshwater biomonitoring and benthic
invertebrates. Chapman and Hall, New York, pp.33-56, 1993.
[5] Griffith, M.B., Hill, B.H., McCormick, F.H., Kaufmann, P.R., Herlihy,
A.T., Selle, A.R. “Comparative application of indices of biotic intergrity
based on periphyton, macroinvertebrates, and fish to southern Rocky
Mountain streams,” Ecological Indicators, vol. 5 no.2, pp.177-136,
2005.
[6] Czerniawska-Kusza, I.,” Comparing modified biological monitoring
working party score system and several biological indices based on
macroinvertebrates for water quality assessment,” Limnologica Ecology
and Management of Inland Waters, vol.35 no.3, pp.169-176, 2005.
[7] De Pauw, N., Gabriels, W.,Goethals, P.L.,” River monitoring and
assessment methods based on macroinvertebrates,” Biological
Monotoring of Rivers, pp.113-134, 2006.
[8] Stark, J.D.,”SQMCI: A biotic index for freshwater macroinvertebrate
coded abundance data,” New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater
Research,vol, 32,no.1, pp.55-66, 1998.
[9] Kalyoncu, H., Zeybeck, M.,” An application of different biotic and
diversity indices for assessing water quality: A case study in the Rivers
Cukurca and Isparta (Turkey), “African Journal of agricultural Research,
vol. 6, no.1,pp.19-27, 2011.
[10] Metcalfe-smith, J.L.,Bilogical water quality assessment of rivers;use of
macroinvertebrate communities. In petts, G., Callow,P. eds. River
Restoration, Blackwell,Oxford, (1996).
[11] Potapova, M., Charles, D.F.,”Diatom metrics for monitoring
eutrophication in rivers of the United States”, Ecological Indicators, vol.
7, no.1, pp.48-70, 2007.
[12] Kelly, M.G., King, L., Jones, R.I., Barker, P.A., Jamieson, B.J.,”
Validation of diatoms as proxies for phytobenthos when assessing
ecological status in lakes,” Hydrobiologia, vol. 610, no.1, pp.125-129,
2008b.
[13] Kelly, M.G., Whitton, B.A.,” The trophic diatom index: a new index for
monitoring eutrophication in rivers,” Journal of Applied Phycology,vol.
7,no.4, pp.433-444, 1995.
[14] Kelly, M.G,”Use of the trophic diatom index to monitor eutrophication
in rivers, “Water Research, 32(1), pp. 236-242, 1998. [15] Huguenny, B., Camara, S., Samoura, B., Magassouba, M.,” Applying an
index of biotic integrity based on fish assemblages in a West African
river, “Hydrobiologia,vol. 331,pp.71-78, 1996.
[16] Belpaire, C., Smolders, R., Auweele, I.V., Ercken, D., Breine, J., Van
Thuyne, G., Ollevier, F.,” An index of Biotic Integrity characterizing
fish populations and the ecological quality of Flandrian water bodies,
“Hydrobiologia, vol. 434, pp. 17-33, 2000.
[17] Iliopoulou-Georgudaki, J., Kantzaris, V., Katharios, P., Kaspiris, P.,
Georgiadis, T., Montesantou, B.” An application of different
bioindicators for assessing water quality: a case study in the rivers
Alfeios and pineios (Peloponnisos, Greece),” Ecological indicators,
vol.2, no.4, pp.345-360, 2003.
[18] Hering, D., Moog, O., Sandin, L., Verdonschot, P.F.,”Overview and
application of the AQEM assessment system,” Hydrobiologia, vol.
516,pp.1-20, 2004.
[19] Directive 20000/60/EC of the European parliament and of the council of
23 Oct.2000 establishing a framework for community action in the field
of water policy, Ojec L 327/1 of 22.12.2000.
[20] Washington, H.G.,” Diversity, biotic and similarity indices: a review
with special relevance to aquatic ecosystems, “Water Research, vol. 18,
no.6, pp.653-694, 1984.
[21] Ghetti, P.F., Ravera, O., European perspective on biological monitoring ,
46. In:Biological Monitoring of Aquatic Systems. Loeb, L., Specie, A.
eds. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, FL, USA, 1994.
[22] Daheygere, T.P., Goethals, P.L., De Pauw, N. “Optimisation of the
monitoring strategy of macroinvertebrate communities in the river
Dender, in relation to the EU Water Frame work Directive,” Scientific
World Journal, vol. 2, pp.607-612, 2002.
[23] Carney, E.,” Relative influence of lake age and watershed land use on
trophic state and water quality lakes in Kansas,”Lake and Reservoir
Management, vol. 25, no.2, pp.199-207,2009.
[24] James, A., Evison, L.,Biologicalindicators of water quality. Chichester.
Wiley interscience: Publication, 1979.
[25] Whitehurst, I.T.,”The Gammarus:Asellus ratio as an index of organic
pollution,” Water Research, vol.25,no.6,pp.333-339, 1991.
[26] Hawkes, H.A. Invertebrates as indicators of River water. In:biological
indicators of water quality. John wiley and sons Chichester, 1979.
[27] MacNeil, C., Dick, J.T., Bigsby, E., Elwood, R.W., Ian Montgomery,
W., Gibbins, C.N., Kelly, D.W., “The validity of the Gammarus:Asellus
ratio as an index of organic pollution: abiotic and biotic influences,
“Water Research,vol., no.36, pp.75-84, 2002.
[28] Meijering, M.P.,” Lack of oxygen and low PH as limiting factors for
Gammarus in Hessian brooks and rivers, “Hydrobiologia, vol. 223,no.1,
pp.159-169, 1994.
[29] Hargeby, A.,” Effects of PH, humic substances and animal interactions
on survival and physiological status of Asellus aquaticus L.and
Gammarus pulex(L),” Oecologia,vol. 82,no.3,pp. 348-354, 1990.
[30] Macan, T.T.,” Factors that limit the range of freshwater animals,”
Biological Reviews, vol.36, no.2, pp.151-148, 1961.
[31] Holland, D.G.,” The distribution of the freshwater Malacostraca in the
area of the Mersy and Weaver River Authority,” Freshwater
Biology,vol. 6,no.3, pp.265-276, 1976.
[32] Bloor, M.C.,Blanks,C.J.,” An evaluation of mixed species in-situ and exsitu
feeding assays: The altered response of Asellus aquaticus and
Gammarus pulex,”Environment international,vol.32,no.1,2006.
[33] Duran, M.,” Monitoring water quality using benthic macroinvertebrates
and physicochemical parameters of Behzat in Turkey, “Polish Journal of
Environmental Studies,vol. 15,no.5, pp.709, 2006.
[34] Whitehurst, I.T., Lindsey, B.I.,” The impact of organic enrichment on
the benthic macroinvertebrate communities of a lowland River, “Water
Research, vol.24, no.5, pp.625-630, 1990.
[35] Azrina, M.Z.,Yap, C.K., Rahim, I.A., Ismail, A., Tan, S.G.,
“Anthropogenic impacts on the distribution and biodiversity of benthic
macroinvertebrates and water quality of the Langat River, Peninsular
Malaysia,”Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, vol.64 no.3,
pp.337-347.,2006.
[36] Varnosfaderany, M.N., Ebrahimi, E., Mirghaffary, N., Safyanian, A.,
“Biological assessment of the Zyandeh Rud River, Iran, using benthic
macroinvertebrates, “Limnologica-Ecology and Management of Inland
Waters, vol.40, no.3, pp.226-232, 2010.
[37] Camargo, J.A., Gonzalo, C., “Physicochemical and biological changes
downstream from a trout farm oulet: comparing 1986 and 2006 sampling
surveys, “Limnetica, vol.26, no.2, pp.405-414, 2007.
[38] Armitage, P.D., Moss, D., Wright, J.F., Furse, M.T.,” The performance
of a new biological water quality score system based on
macroinvertebrate over a wide range of unpolluted running water sites,
“Water Research, vol.6,no.3,pp. 333-347, 1983.
[39] WildLifeTrust,Avalaibleat: http://www.dcpwa.org.uk/Reports/Allestree-
Park-Lake.html [assessed 20 October, 2013], 2011.
[40] Ordinance Survey Edition, Landranger map 128 Derby and Burton
uponTrent, Scale 1:50 000, 2002.
[41] Bartram, J.,Balance, R., Water quality monitoring: A practical guide to
the design and implementation of fresh water quality studies and
monitoring programmes. E and FN Spon: Podstow, 1996.
[42] Quigley, M. Invertebrate of streams and rivers, A key to identification.
London: Edward Arnold Publishers, 1977.
[43] Croft, P.S. A key to the major groups of British fresh water invertebrate,
Field Studies 6, pp. 531-579, 1986.
[44] Fitter,R.,Manuel,R., Lakes,Rivers,Streams and Pond of Britain and
North –West Europe.Harper Collins publishers.London., 1995.
[45] Dobson, M., Pawley, S., Fletcher, M., Powell, A. Guide to freshwater
invertebrates, Freshawater Biological Association,68.:Cambria. , 2012.
[46] Wallace, I. Simple key to caddis larvae. Liverpool: World Meseum.,
2006.
[47] Wahizatul, A.A., Long, S.H., Ahmad,A.,” Taxonomic composition of
macroinvertebrates in the Liwiec River and its tributaries (Central and
Eastern Poland) on the basis of chosen physical and chemical parameters
of water and season,” Polish journal of Environmental Studies,vol.
17,no.1, pp.39., 2011.
[48] Dytham, C., Chosing and using statistics, a biologist guide. 3rd
ed:Wiley-Blackwell. , 2011.
[49] Chapman, D., ed., Water quality Assessment, A guide to the use of
biota, sediments and water in environmental monitoring . E and FN
Spon Publishers: London, 1996.
[50] Hynes, H.B.N. ,The ecology of running waters. Liverpool University
Press. Liverpool, 1970.
[51] Erman, D.C., Ligon, F.K.,” Effects of dischsrge fluction and the addition
of sediment on stream fish and macroinvertebrate below a water
filtration facility,” Environmetal Management, vol.12 ,no. 1, pp.85-97.,
1988.
[52] Doeg, T.J., Milledge, G.A.,”Effect of experimentally increasing
concentration of suspended sediment on macroinvertebrate drift,
“Marine and Freshwater Research,vol. 42,no.5, pp.519-526., 1991.
[53] Zamora-Munoz, C., Sainz-Cantero, C.E., Sanchez-Ortega, A., Alba-
Tercedor, J.,” Are biological indices BMWP and ASPT and their
significance regarding water quality seasonally dependent? Factors
explaining their variations,” Water Research,vol. 29,no.1, pp.285-290.,
1995.
[54] Soldner, M., Stephen, I., Ramos, L., Angus, R., Wells, N.C., Grosso, A.,
Crane, M.,” Relationship between macroinvertebrate fauna and
environmental variables in small streams of the Dominican Republic,
“Water Research, vol.38,no.4,pp. 863-874., 2004.
[55] Gray, N.F., Delaney, E.,” Comparison of benthic macroinvertebrate
indices for the impact of acid mine drainage on an Irish river below an
abandoned CU-S mine,” Environmetal Pollution, vol.155, no. 1, pp.31-
40., 2008.
[56] Kobingi, N., Raburu, P.O., Masese, F.O., Gichuki, J. ,”Assessment of
pollution impacts on the ecological integrity of the Kisian and Kisat
rivers in Lake Victoria drainage basin, Kenya, African of,”
Environmental Science and Technology,vol. 3,no.4,pp.097-107., 2009.
[57] Giller, P.S., Malmqvist, B. The Biology of streams and Rivers. New
York: Oxford University Press. 1998.
[58] Allan, D.J. Stream Ecology, structure and function of running waters.
Chapman and Hall: London, 1995.
[59] Dewson, Z.S., James, A.B.W., Death, R.G.,”A review of the
consequences of decreased flow for instream habitat and
macroinvertebrates, “Journal of the North American Benthological
Society,vol. 26.,no.3, pp.401-415., 2007.
[60] Erman, D.C., Ligon, F.K. “Effects of dischsrge fluction and the addition
of sediment on stream fish and macroinvertebrate below a water
filtration facility,” Environmetal Management,vol. 12,no.1, pp.85-97.,
1988.
[61] Armitage, P.D. Faunal community change in response to flow
manipulation. 1995.
[62] Kaller,M.D., Hartman, K.,” Evidence of a threshold level of fine
sediment accumulation for altering benthic macroinvertebrate
communities, “Hydrobiologia,vol. 518,no.3, pp.95-104., 2004.
[63] Donohue, I., Irvine, K.,” Seasonal patterns of sediment loading and
benthic invertebrate community dynamics in Lake Tanganyika, Africa,
“Freshwater biology,vol. 49,no.39, pp.320-331., 2004.[64] Manny, B.A., Johnson, W.C., Wetzel, R.G.,” Nutrient additions by
waterfowl to lakes and reservoirs: predicting their effects on productivity
and water quality, “In Aquatic Birds in the Trophic Wed of Lakes,
Springer Netherlands,pp.121-132., 1994.
[65] Post, D.m., Taylor,J.P., Kitchell, J.F., Olson, M.H., Schindler, D.E.,
Herwig, B.R.,” The role of migratory waterfowl as nutrient vectors in a
managed wetland,” Conservation Biology, vol.12,no.4, pp.910-920.,
1998.
[66] Olson, M.H., Hage, M.M., Binkley,M.D., Binder, J.R.,”Impact of
migratory snow geese on nitrogen and phosphorous dynamics in a
freshwater reservoir, “Freshwater Biology, vol.50,no.5,pp.882-890.,
2005.
[67] Kitchell, J.F.,Schindler, D.E., Herwig, B.R., Post, D.M., Oslon, M.H.,
Oldham, M.,” Nutrient cycling at the landscape scale: the role of diet
foraging migrations by geese at the Bosque del Apache National
Wildlife Refuge, New Mexico,” Limnology and Oceanography,
vol.44,no.3, 828-836., 1999.