The Application of Real Options to Capital Budgeting

Real options theory suggests that managerial flexibility embedded within irreversible investments can account for a significant value in project valuation. Although the argument has become the dominant focus of capital investment theory over decades, yet recent survey literature in capital budgeting indicates that corporate practitioners still do not explicitly apply real options in investment decisions. In this paper, we explore how real options decision criteria can be transformed into equivalent capital budgeting criteria under the consideration of uncertainty, assuming that underlying stochastic process follows a geometric Brownian motion (GBM), a mixed diffusion-jump (MX), or a mean-reverting process (MR). These equivalent valuation techniques can be readily decomposed into conventional investment rules and “option impacts", the latter of which describe the impacts on optimal investment rules with the option value considered. Based on numerical analysis and Monte Carlo simulation, three major findings are derived. First, it is shown that real options could be successfully integrated into the mindset of conventional capital budgeting. Second, the inclusion of option impacts tends to delay investment. It is indicated that the delay effect is the most significant under a GBM process and the least significant under a MR process. Third, it is optimal to adopt the new capital budgeting criteria in investment decision-making and adopting a suboptimal investment rule without considering real options could lead to a substantial loss in value.

• George Yungchih Wang

• real options
• capital budgeting
• geometric Brownianmotion
• mixed diffusion-jump
• mean-reverting process

[1] Arnold, Glen C. and Hatzopoulos, Panos D. "The Theory-Practice Gap in
Capital Budgeting: Evidence from the United Kingdom." Journal of
Business Finance and Accounting, 27, 5 and 6 (2000), 603-626.
[2] Boyle, Glenn W. and Gutherie, Graeme A. "Payback and the Value of
Waiting to Invest." Working Paper (1997), University of Otago, New
Zealand.
[3] Busby, J. S. and Pitts, C. G. C. "Real Options in Practice: an Exploratory
Survey of How Finance Officers Deal with Flexibility in Capital
Appraisal." Management Accounting Research, 8, 2 (1997), 169-186.
[4] Dixit, Avinash "Entry and Exit Decisions under Uncertainty." Journal of
Political Economy, 97 (1989), 620-638.
[5] Dixit, Avinash "Investment and Hysteresis." Journal of Economic
Perspectives 6 (1992), 107-132.
[6] Dixit, Avinash K. and Pindyck, Robert S. Investment under Uncertainty
(1994). Princeton University Press, New Jersey, USA.
[7] Gilbert, Erika and Reichert, Alan. "The Practice of Financial Management
among Large United States Corporations." Financial Practice and
Education, 5, 1 (1995), 16-23.
[8] Ingersoll, Jonathan E. and Ross, Stephen A. "Waiting to Invest:
Investment and Uncertainty." Journal of Business, 65, 1 (1992), 1-29.
[9] Jog, Vijay M. and Srivastava, Ashwani K.. "Capital Budgeting Practices
in Corporate Canada." Financial Practice and Education, 5, 2 (1995),
37-43.
[10] Klammer, Thomas P. "Empirical Evidence of the Adoption of
Sophisticated Capital Budgeting Techniques." Journal of Business, 45, 3
(1972), 387-397.
[11] Klammer, Thomas P. and Walker, Michael C. "The Continuing Increase
in the Use of Sophisticated Capital Budgeting Techniques." California
Management Review, 27, 1 (1984) 137-148.
[12] McDonald, Robert L. "Real Options and Rules of Thumb in Capital
Budgeting." Project Flexibility, Agency, and Competition, ed. by
Brennan, Michael J. and Trigeorgis, Lenos. Oxford University Press
(1999), NY, USA.
[13] McDonald, Robert and Siegel, Daniel. "The Value of Waiting to Invest."
Quarterly Journal of Economics, 101 (1986), 707-728.
[14] Pindyck, Robert S. "Irreversibility, Uncertainty, and Investment." Journal
of Economic Literature, 29 (1991), 1110-1148.
[15] Sarkar, Sudipto. "The Effect of Mean Reversion on Investment under
Uncertainty." Journal of Economics Dynamics and Control, 28 (2003),
377-396.
[16] Schwartz, Eduardo S. "Stochastic Behavior of Commodity Prices:
Implications for Valuation and Hedging." Journal of Finance, 52 (1997),
923-973.
[17] Trigeorgis, Lenos. "Valuing the Impact of the Uncertain Competitive
Arrivals on Deferrable Real Investment Opportunities." Working Paper,
Boston University (1990).
[18] Wambach, Achim. "Payback Criterion, Hurdle Rates, and the Gain of
Waiting." International Review of Financial Analysis, 9, 3 (2000),
247-258.