Potential of Irish Orientated Strand Board in Bending Active Structures

To determine the potential of a low cost Irish
engineered timber product to replace high cost solid timber for use in
bending active structures such as gridshells a single Irish engineered
timber product in the form of orientated strand board (OSB) was
selected. A comparative study of OSB and solid timber was carried
out to determine the optimum properties that make a material suitable
for use in gridshells. Three parameters were identified to be relevant
in the selection of a material for gridshells. These three parameters
are the strength to stiffness ratio, the flexural stiffness of
commercially available sections, and the variability of material and
section properties. It is shown that when comparing OSB against
solid timber, OSB is a more suitable material for use in gridshells that
are at the smaller end of the scale and that have tight radii of
curvature. Typically, for solid timber materials, stiffness is used as an
indicator for strength and engineered timber is no different. Thus, low
flexural stiffness would mean low flexural strength. However, when
it comes to bending active gridshells, OSB offers a significant
advantage. By the addition of multiple layers, an increased section
size is created, thus endowing the structure with higher stiffness and
higher strength from initial low stiffness and low strength materials
while still maintaining tight radii of curvature. This allows OSB to
compete with solid timber on large scale gridshells. Additionally, a
preliminary sustainability study using a set of sustainability indicators
was carried out to determine the relative sustainability of building a
large-scale gridshell in Ireland with a primary focus on economic
viability but a mention is also given to social and environmental
aspects. For this, the Savill garden gridshell in the UK was used as
the functional unit with the sustainability of the structural roof
skeleton constructed from UK larch solid timber being compared
with the same structure using Irish OSB. Albeit that the advantages of
using commercially available OSB in a bending active gridshell are
marginal and limited to specific gridshell applications, further study
into an optimised engineered timber product is merited.

• M. Collins
• B. O’Regan
• T. Cosgrove

• Bending active gridshells
• High end timber structures
• Low cost material
• Sustainability.

[1] Lienhard, J., Alpermann, H., Gengnagel, C., & Knippers, J. (2013).
Active bending, a review on structures where bending is used as a selfformation
process. International Journal of Space Structures, 28(3-4),
187-196.
[2] Happold, E., & Liddell, W. (1975). Timber lattice roof for the
Mannheim Bundesgartenschau. The Structural Engineer, 53(3), 99-135.
[3] Harris, R., Romer, J., Kelly, O., & Johnson, S. (2003). Design and
construction of the Downland Gridshell. Building Research &
Information, 31(6), 427-454. doi: 10.1080/0961321032000088007
[4] Harris, R., Haskins, S., & Roynon, J. (2008). The Savill Garden
gridshell: design and construction. The Structural Engineer, 28.
[5] Harris, R., Roynon, J., & Happold, B. (2008). The savill garden
gridshell: Design and construction. The Structural Engineer, 86, 27-34
[6] Paoli, C. C. A. (2007). Past and future of grid shell structures.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. [7] Douthe, C., Baverel, O., & Caron, J. (2006). Form-finding of a grid shell
in composite materials. Journal-International association for shell and
Spatial Structures, 150, 53.
[8] McConville Wellburn (2011) Friends of the Earth Scotland (online),
available: http://www.foe-scotland.org.uk/ (accessed 16/01/2014).
[9] Toussaint, M. H. (2007). A Design Tool for Timber Gridshells: The
development of a Grid Generation Tool. Msc thesis Delft University of
Technoloy, online http://homepage.tudelft.nl/p3r3s/MSc_projecs/
reportToussaint. pdf.
[10] Lienhard, J. (2014) Bending-active structures: form-finding strategies
using elastic deformation in static and kinetic systems and the structural
potentials therein, unpublished thesis Universitätsbibliothek der
Universität Stuttgart.
[11] Ashby, M. F. (1999) Materials selection in mechanical design, Boston,
MA: Butterworth-Heinemann.
[12] EN338 (2009) 'Structural Timber - Strength Classes',
[13] Institution of Structural, E. and Technology, T. (2007) Manual for the
design of timber building structures to Eurocode 5, London: The
Institution of Structural Engineers.
[14] EN 1995-1-1:2004 'Eurocode 5: Design of timber structures - Part 1-1:
General - Common rules and rules for buildings',
[15] EN14358 (2006) 'Timber structures - Calculation of characteristic 5-
percentile values and acceptance criteria for a sample', National
Standards Authority of Ireland,
[16] EN789 (2004) 'Timber structures - Test methods - Determination of
mechanical properties of wood based panels', National Standards
Authority of Ireland,
[17] Collins and Cosgrove unpublished
[18] TECO. (2011, 14 Oct 2014). OSB Guide. History of OSB, from
http://osbguide.tecotested.com/osbhistory