Challenges in Adopting 3R Concept in the Heritage Building Restoration

Malaysia is rich with historic buildings, particularly in
Penang and Malacca states. Restoration activities are increasingly
important as these states are recognized under UNESCO World
Heritage Sites. Restoration activities help to maintain the uniqueness
and value of a heritage building. However, increasing in restoration
activities has resulted in large quantities of waste. To cope with this
problem, the 3R concept (reduce, reuse and recycle) is introduced.
The 3R concept is one of the waste management hierarchies. This
concept is still yet to apply in the building restoration industry
compared to the construction industry. Therefore, this study aims to
promote the 3R concept in the heritage building restoration industry.
This study aims to examine the importance of 3R concept and to
identify challenges in applying the 3R concept in the heritage
building restoration industry. This study focused on contractors and
consultants who are involved in heritage restoration projects in
Penang. Literature review and interviews helps to reach the research
objective. Data that obtained is analyzed by using content analysis.
For the research, application of 3R concept is important to conserve
natural resources and reduce pollution problems. However, limited
space to organise waste is the obstruction during the implementation
of this concept. In conclusion, the 3R concept plays an important role
in promoting environmental conservation and helping in reducing the
construction waste.

• H. H. Goh
• K. C. Goh
• T. W. Seow
• N. S. Said
• S. E. P. Ang

• 3R Concept
• Heritage building
• Restoration activities.

[1] Ahmad, A. G. (2009) Treatment of rising damp and replastering at
heritage buildings. Paper presented at the Bengkel Bersiri Konservasi
Bangunan Warisan Siri 2: Lepaan Kapur.
[2] Babbie, E. (2005) The Basics of Social Research. 3th ed. Thomson
Wadsworth.
[3] Balaras, C. A. (2002) TOBUS-A European method and software for
office building refurbishment. Energy and Buildings. 34(2). 111-112.
[4] Barret, A., & Lawlor, J. (1995) The economic of waste management in
Ireland.
[5] Burden, E. (2004) Illustrated Dictionary of Architectural Preservation.
Mc Graw Hill,New York.
[6] Burn, R. B. (1995) Introduction to Research Methods. 4th ed.
Melbourne: Longman.
[7] Carr, L. T. (2008) The strengths and weaknesses of quantitative and
qualitative research: what method for nursing, Journal of advanced
nursing. 20(4). 716-721.
[8] CIDB (2007). Construction Quarterly Statistical Bulletin-Fourth Quarter
2006: CIDB,Malaysia.
[9] City of Austin Green Building Program. (2003). Sustainable building
Sourcebook. City of Austin.
[10] DE, M. (2010). "Market Watch 2010" The Environment Sector in
Malaysia: German Chamber of Commerce & Industry
[11] Dolan, P. J., Lampo, R. G., & Dearborn, J. C. (1999). Concepts for reuse
and recycling of construction and demolition waste: DTIC Document.
[12] Emmanuel, M. (2011). Penang heritage zone 'refresh'. Business Times.
[13] Ferguson, J. (1995). Managing and minimizing construction waste: a
practical guide.
[14] Gateway, E.-W. (2005). Environmental Benefit of Recycling Study.
Paper presented at the St.Louis-Jefferson Solid Waste Management
District.
[15] Guide, C. (2003). Save money and resources through job-site recycling
and waste prevention. Paper presented at the Business and Industry
Resource Venture and King Country Solid Waste Division (2002-2003).
[16] Heimlich, J. E., Hughes, K. L., & Christy, A. D. (1992). Integrated solid
waste management. Publication-Louisiana Cooperative Extension
Service.
[17] Hill, R. C., & Bowen, P. A. (1997) Sustainable construction: principles
and a framework for attainment. Construction Management &
Economics. 15(3). 223-239.
[18] Kajornboon, A. B. (2005). Using interviews as research instruments. EJournal
for Research Teachers.. 2(1).
[19] Khoramshahi, F., Dehghan, R., & Mortaheb, M. (2007). Waste
Management Practices in Construction Sites.
[20] Laustsen, G. (2007) Reduce, recycle, reuse : guidelines for promoting
perioperative waste management. AORN Journal. 85(4). 717-722.
[21] Memon, M. A. (2010) Integrated solid waste management based on 3R
approach. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management.. 12(1).
30-40.
[22] M.O.E. (2005). The 3R Initiative: Policy Planning Division, Waste
Management and Recycling Department,Ministry of the Environment
[23] McTavish, D. G., & Loether, H. J. Social Research. 2nd ed. Allyn and
Bacon. (2002). Merriem, S. B. Qualitative Research and Case Study
Applications in Education. 2nd ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. 1998.
Morgan, R.2002. Waste management strategy
[24] Morris, J. (1996) Recycling versus incineration: an energy conservation
analysis. Journal of Hazardous Materials.. 47(1). 277-293.
[25] Nisbet, M., & Ave, L. (2003) Demolition and Deconstruction: Review of
the Current Status of Reuse and Recycling of Building Materials.
[26] Ong, E. G. (2009) Construction Waste Generated in Conventional
method of Housing Construction degree of Master of Science
(Construction Management). Universiti Teknologi Malaysia.
[27] Saidi, S. B. (2007) Pengurusan dan Potensi Kitar Semula Bahan
Buangan Pembinaan. Ijazah Sarjana Muda Kejuruteraan Awam.
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia.
[28] Samadi, Z. H., & Mahmud, S. A. M., M. (2008) Pemuliharaan Warisan
Senibina Rumah Kedai Bagi Kemakmuran Bandar: Isu dan Cabaran.
Jabatan Senibina Fakulti Senibina Perancangan dan ukur Univeristi
teknologi MARA. .
[29] SANYO. (2011). Hotel Penaga partners with SANYO to receive Green
Mark Certification in Malaysia: SANYO Asia Pte Ltd.
[30] Serpo, A. (2012). Four Barriers to better C&D recovery: BEN Waste.
[31] Shah.R.A, & Pitroda, .J.R. (2011) Recycling of Construction Materials
for sustainability. Paper presented at the National Conference on Recent
Trends in Engineering & Technology.
[32] Stemler, S. (2001) An overview of content analysis. Practical
assessment, research & evaluation. 7(17). 137-146.
[33] Tey, J. S., Goh, K. C., Seow, T. W., & Goh, H. H. (2013) Challenges in
adopting sustainable materials in Malaysian construction industry. 301-
305.
[34] Triangle, J., Kincaid, J. E., Walker, C., & Flynn, G. (1995). WasteSpec:
Model Specifications for Construction Waste Reduction, Reuse, and
Recycling: Triangle J Council of Governments.
[35] Tye, T. (2008). Introducing the World Heritage Site of George Town,
George Town UNESCO World Heritage Site World heritage Site Home.
[36] Walther, R. Builders' (1993) Guidebook to Reducing, Reusing and
Recycling Residential Construction Waste in Wisconsin.
[37] Zero Waste Explained (2010). Reduce, Reuse, Recycle and Recover:
Edinburgh & Midlothian.