Water Saving in Arid Regions: Comparison of Innovative Techniques for Irrigation of Young Date Palms

In oases, the surface water resources are becoming
increasingly scarce and groundwater resources, which generally have
a poor quality due to the high levels of salinity, are often
overexploited. Water saving have therefore become imperative for
better oases sustainability. If drip irrigation is currently recommended
in Morocco for saving water and valuing, its use in the sub-desert
areas does not keep water safe from high evaporation rates. An
alternative to this system would be the use of subsurface drip
irrigation. This technique is defined as an application of water under
the soil surface through drippers, which deliver water at rates
generally similar to surface drip irrigation. As subsurface drip
irrigation is a recently introduced in Morocco, a better understanding
of the infiltration process around a buried source, in local conditions,
and its impact on plant growth is necessarily required. This study
aims to contribute to improving the water use efficiency by testing
the performance of subsurface irrigation system, especially in areas
where water is a limited source. The objectives of this research are
performance evaluation in arid conditions of the subsurface drip
irrigation system for young date palms compared to the surface drip.
In this context, an experimental test is installed at a farmer’s field in
the area of Erfoud (Errachidia Province, southeastern Morocco),
using the subsurface drip irrigation system in comparison with the
classic drip system for young date palms. Flow measurement to
calculate the uniformity of the application of water was done through
two methods: a flow measurement of drippers above the surface and
another one underground. The latter method has also helped us to
estimate losses through evaporation for both irrigation techniques. In
order to compare the effect of two irrigation modes, plants were
identified for each type of irrigation to monitor certain agronomic
parameters (cumulative numbers of palms and roots development).
Experimentation referred to a distribution uniformity of about 88%;
considered acceptable for subsurface drip irrigation while it is around
80% for the surface drip irrigation. The results also show an increase
in root development and in the number of palm, as well as a
substantial water savings due to lower evaporation losses compared
to the classic drip irrigation.
The results of this study showed that subsurface drip irrigation is
an efficient technique, which allows sustainable irrigation in arid
areas.

• R. Bourziza
• A. Hammani
• M. Kuper
• A. Bouaziz

• Subsurface drip irrigation
• Water conservation
• Arid areas
• Young date palms.

[1] ASAE Std., 1999. Soil and Water Terminology. S 526.1. ASAE
Standards. American Society of Agricultural Engineers, St. Joseph M.I..
[2] A.I. Al-Amoud., M.A. Bacha and A.M. Al-Darby. Seasonal water use of
date palms in Central Region of Saudi Arabia. Agricultural Engineering
Journal 9(2), 2000 pp: 51-62.
[3] B. Hanson and D. May. The effect of drip line placement on yield and
quality of drip irrigated processing tomatoes. Irrig. Drainage Syst N°21.
2007, pp: 109-118.
[4] Safi B., Neyshabouri M.R. and Nazem A.H., 2007. Water Application
Uniformity of Subsurface Drip Irrigation System at Various Operating
Pressures and tape Lengths. Turk J. of Agric.and Forest. 31(2007): 275-
285.
[5] Singh D.K., Rajput T.B.S, 2007. Response of lateral placement depths of
subsurface drip irrigation on okra (Abelmoschus esculentus).
International Journal of Plant Production, 1, pp 73-84.
[6] Ayers J.E., Phene C.J., Schoneman R.A., Meso B., Dale F. and Penland
J., 1995. Impact of bed location on the operation of subsurface drip
irrigation systems. In: Proc. 5th int.Microirrigation Congress, ASAE,
p.168-174.
[7] Tiwari K.N., MalP.K., Singh R.M.et ChattopadhyayA., 1998. Response
of Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus”L.” Moench) to drip irrigation under
mulch and non-mulch condition. Agric. Water Manage. 38, pp 91-102.
[8] Thompson T.L., Doerge T.A.et GodinR.E., 2002. Subsurface drip
irrigation and fertigation of broccoli: agronomic, economic, and
environmental outcomes and environmental outcomes. Soil Sci. Soc.
Am. J., 66, pp 178-185.
[9] Thompson T.L., WhiteS.A., Walworth J.L. et SowerG.S., 2003.
Fertigation Frequency for Subsurface Drip-Irrigated Broccoli, Soil Sci.
Soc. Am. J., 67, pp 910-918.
[10] Douh B. and BoujelbenA., 2010 (a), Water saving and eggplant response
to subsurface drip irrigation. Journal of Agricultural Segment, 1 (2):
1525, pp 1-12.
[11] Payero J., 2002. Is subsurface drip irrigation right for your operations?.
Crop watch new service web page, Univ. of Nebraska, Institute of
Agriculture and Natural Resources Cooperative Extension.
[12] Patel N., Rajput T.B.S., 2008. Dynamics and modeling of soil water
under subsurface drip irrigated onion. Agricultural water management
95, 1335 – 1349.
[13] Ayars J.E., Phene C.J., Hutmacher R.B., Davis K.R., Schoneman R.A.,
Vail S.S. and Mead R.M., 1999. Subsurface drip irrigation of row crops: a review of 15 years of research at the Water Management Research
laboratory. Agric. Water Manage. 42 (1999): 1-27. 1999.
[14] Enciso J., Jifon J.et Wiedenfeld B., 2007, Subsurface drip irrigation of
onions: Effects of drip tape emitter spacing on yield and quality. J. Agr.
Water Manage, 92, pp 126–130.
[15] A.I. Al-Amoud, “Subsurface Drip Irrigation for Date Palm Trees to
Conserve Water”. Acta Hort. 882, ISHS 2010.
[16] Qassim A., 2003. Subsurface irrigation: A situation analysis. Intern. In:
Prog. For Technology and Res. In Irrigation and Drainage (IPTRID),
Tatura, Australia.
[17] Keller J. and Karmeli D., 1974. Trickle irrigation design parameters.
Transactions of the ASAE Vol. 24(4): 678-684.
[18] Singh D.K., 2004. Performance evaluation of subsurface drip irrigation
systems. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, P.G. School, IARI, New Delhi, 135
pp.
[19] Meshkat M., Warner R.C., Workman S.R., 2000. Evaporation reduction
potential in an undisturbed soil irrigated with surface and sand tube
irrigation. Transactions of ASAE 43, 79–86.
[20] Philip J.R., 1991a. Upper bounds on evaporation losses from buried
sources. Soil Science Society of America Journal 55, 1516–1520.
[21] Philip J.R., 1991b. Effect of root and sub irrigation on evaporation and
percolation losses. Soil Science Society of America Journal 55, 1520–
1523.
[22] Thompson T.L., Pang H, Li Y., 2009. The Potential Contribution of
Subsurface Drip Irrigation to Water-Saving Agriculture in the Western
USA. Agr. Sci. in China, Vol. 8, Issue 7: 850-854.
[23] Douh B., Boujelben A., 2007. Effet du système d’irrigation goutte à
goutte souterrain sur une culture d’aubergine. Séminaire international,
Exploitation des ressources en eau pour une agriculture durable.
Hammamet-Tunisie 21 et 22 novembre, in Abstract book, p70.
[24] Vermeiren L., Jobling G.A., 1980. Localized irrigation: design -
installation - operation – evaluation. FAO irrigation and drainage paper,
36, pp 8.