Tribological Investigation and the Effect of Karanja Biodiesel on Engine Wear in Compression Ignition Engine

Various biomass based resources, which can be used
as an extender, or a complete substitute of diesel fuel may have very
significant role in the development of agriculture, industrial and
transport sectors in the energy crisis. Use of Karanja oil methyl ester
biodiesel in a CI DI engine was found highly compatible with engine
performance along with lower exhaust emission as compared to
diesel fuel but with slightly higher NOx emission and low wear
characteristics. The combustion related properties of vegetable oils
are somewhat similar to diesel oil. Neat vegetable oils or their blends
with diesel, however, pose various long-term problems in
compression ignition engines. These undesirable features of
vegetable oils are because of their inherent properties like high
viscosity, low volatility, and polyunsaturated character. Pongamia
methyl ester (PME) was prepared by transesterification process using
methanol for long term engine operations. The physical and
combustion-related properties of the fuels thus developed were found
to be closer to that of the diesel. A neat biodiesel (PME) was selected
as a fuel for the tribological study of biofuels.
Two similar new engines were completely disassembled and
subjected to dimensioning of various vital moving parts and then
subjected to long-term endurance tests on neat biodiesel and diesel
respectively. After completion of the test, both the engines were
again disassembled for physical inspection and wear measurement of
various vital parts. The lubricating oil samples drawn from both
engines were subjected to atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) for
measurement of various wear metal traces present. The additional
lubricating property of biodiesel fuel due to higher viscosity as
compared to diesel fuel resulted in lower wear of moving parts and
thus improved the engine durability with a bio-diesel fuel. Results
reported from AAS tests confirmed substantially lower wear and thus
improved life for biodiesel operated engines.

• Ajay V. Kolhe
• R. E. Shelke
• S. S. Khandare

• Transesterification
• PME
• wear of engine parts
• Metal traces and AAS.

[1] Agarwal A.K., Bijwe and Das,"Wear assessment in a biodiesel fueled
compression ignition engine”, ASME,Vol.125, Jully 2003.
[2] Agarwal A.K., Bijwe and Das, "Effect of biodiesel utilization of wear of
vital parts in compression ignition engine”, ASME, Vol.125, April 2003.
[3] Agrawal Deepak, Sinha S., Agrawal A., "Experimental investigation of
control of NOx emissions in Biodiesel-fueled Compression ignition
engine.”, 6 December 2005, Renewable Energy.
[4] Labeckas G., Slavinskas S.., "The effect of rapeseed oil methyl ester on
a direct injection diesel engine performance and exhaust emissions”.,
Energy Conversion and Management 11(2005),1-14.
[5] D. Karonis, G. Anastopoulos, E. Lois, S. Stournas, F. Zannikos and A.
Serdari, "Assessment of the Lubricity Greek Road Diesel and the Effect
of the Addition of Specific Types of Biodiesel”, SAE paper No.1999-01-
1471.
[6] G.Anastopoulos, E.Lois, S.Stournas, F.Zannikos and A. Serdari;
"Assessment of The Lubricity of Reek Road Diesel and the Effect Of
The Addition of Specific Types of Biodiesel”.SAE, 1999-01-1471
[7] Harold K. Speidal and Irshad Ahmed,”Biodegradability characteristics
of current and newly developed alternate fuels.” SAE,1999-01-3518.
[8] L.Schumacher, S.C.Borgelt,Hires,Wetherell and Nevils,” 100000 Mile
of Fueling 5.9L Cummins Engines With 100%Biodiesel.”SAE.962233.
[9] S.K. Karmee, A. Chadha, "Preparation of biodiesel from crude oil of
Pongamia Pinnata”, Bioresource Technology 96(2005), 1425-1429.
[10] K. Anand, R.P.Sharma, P.S.Mehta, "Experimental investigations on
combustion, performance and emission characteristics of neat karanji
biodiesel and its methanol blend in a diesel engine” , Biomass and
bioenergy 35 (2011) 533-541.
[11] P.V.Rao, "Experimental investigations on the influence of properties of
Jatropha biodiesel on performance, combustion and emission
characteristics of a DI-CI engine” , World academy of science,
engineering and technology 75 (2011) 855-867.
[12] A.S. Ramadhas, C. Muraleedharan., "Performance and emission
evaluation of a diesel engine fueled with methyl esters of rubber seed
oil”., RenewableEnergy30(2005),1789-1800.
[13] Mustafa C., Eradil A., Arcaklioglu E., "Performance and Exhaust
emissions of a Biodiesel engine”, Applied Energy 83(2006), 594-605.
[14] Anand Kumar Pandey and M R Nandgaonkar, "Experimental
Investigation of the Effect of Esterified Karanja Oil Biodiesel on
Performance, Emission and Engine Wear of a Military 160hp
Turbocharged CIDI Engine” Proceedings of the World Congress on
Engineering 2011 Vol III WCE 2011, July 6 - 8, 2011, London, U.K.
[15] Stanislav Pehan, Marta Svoljšak Jerman, "Biodiesel influence on
tribology characteristics of a diesel engine”, Elsevier, Fuel 88 (2009) pp
970–979.
[16] Jianbo Hu, Zexue Du, "Study on the lubrication properties of biodiesel
as fuel lubricity enhancers” , Elsevier Fuel 84 (2005) pp 1601–1606.