The Ethics of Instream Flows: Science and Policy in Southern Alberta, Canada

Securing instream flows for aquatic ecosystems is critical for sustainable water management and the promotion of human and environmental health. Using a case study from the semiarid region of southern Alberta (Canada) this paper considers how the determination of instream flow standards requires judgments with respect to: (1) The relationship between instream flow indicators and assessments of overall environmental health; (2) The indicators used to determine adequate instream flows, and; (3) The assumptions underlying efforts to model instream flows given data constraints. It argues that judgments in each of these areas have an inherently ethical component because instream flows have direct effects on the water(s) available to meet obligations to humans and non-humans. The conclusion expands from the case study to generic issues regarding instream flows, the growing water ethics literature and prospects for linking science to policy.

Authors:

• Jeremy J. Schmidt

Keywords:

• ethics
• instream flows
• policy
• science
• watermanagement

References:

[1] Annear, T.C., I. Chisholm, H. Beecher, A. Locke, P. Aarrestad, C.
Coomer, C. Estes, J. Hunt, R. Jacobson, G. Jobsis, J. Kauffman, J.
Marshall, K. Mayes, G. Smith, C. Stalnaker, R. Wentworth (2004).
Instream flows for riverine resource stewardship, Revised Edition.
Instream Flow Council. Cheyenne, WY, USA.
[2] Postel, S. and B. Richter (2003). Rivers for life: managing water for
people and Nature. Washington DC: Island Press.
[3] Fairweather, Peter (1999). State of environment indicators of ÔÇÿriver
health-: exploring the metaphor. Freshwater Biology 41: 211-220.
[4] Young, M. and J. McColl (2005). Defining tradable water entitlements
and allocations: a robust system. Canadian Water Resources Journal
30(1): 65-72.
[5] Klug, H. (2002). Straining the law: conflicting legal premises and the
governance of aquatic resources. Society and Natural Resources, 15:
693-707.
[6] Butler, L. (2000). The pathology of property norms: living with nature-s
boundaries. Southern California Law Review, 73: 927-1016.
[7] Syme, G., Porter, N., Goeft, U., and E. Kington (2008). Integrating
social well being into assessments of water policy: meeting the
challenge for decision makers. Water Policy, 10: 323-343.
[8] Kay, J. (2000). Ecosystems as self-organizing holarchic open systems:
narratives and the second law of thermodynamics. In S. J├©rgensen and
F. M├╝ller (eds) Handbook of Ecosystem Theories and Management
(CRC Press) pp. 135-160.
[9] Polanyi, K. (1958). Personal knowledge: towards a post-critical
philosophy. New York: Harper and Row.
[10] Norton, B.G. (2005). Sustainability: a philosophy of adaptive
ecosystem management. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
[11] Krippendorff, K. (2004). Content analysis: an introduction to its
methodology 2nd ed. Sage Publications: Thousand Oaks, CA.
[12] Brown, P.G. and J.J. Schmidt (eds) (2010). Water ethics: foundational
readings for students and professionals. Washington DC: Island Press.
[13] Llamas, R., L. Martinez-Cortina and A. Mukherji (eds) (2009). Water
ethics: Marcelino Botin water forum 2007. London: CRC Press.
[14] Bakker, Karen (ed) (2007). Eau Canada: the future of Canada-s water.
Vancouver: UBC Press.
[15] Palliser, John (1860). Further papers relative to the expedition under
Captain Palliser of that portion of British North America which lies
between the northern branch of the river Saskatchewan and the frontier
of the United States; And between the Red River and Rocky Mountains,
and thence to the Pacific Ocean. London: George Edward Eyre and
William Spottiswoode.
[16] Mitchner, E.A. (1967). William Pearce and federal government
activity in the west, 1874-1904. Canadian Public Administration,
10(2): 235-243.
[17] Schindler, D. W. (2001).The cumulative effects of climate warming and other
human stresses on Canadian freshwaters in the new millennium. Canadian
Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 58: 18-29.
[18] Hopkinson, Chris and Gordon J. Young (1998). The effect of glacier
wastage on the flow of the Bow River at Banff, Alberta, 1951-1993.
Hydrologic Processes, 12: 1745-1762.
[19] Percy D. (1997). Seventy-five years of Alberta water law: maturity, demise &
rebirth. Alberta Law Review, 35: 221-241.
[20] Alberta Environment (2005). South Saskatchewan River Basin water
allocation (revised). Regional Services, southern region.
[21] Alberta Environment (2004). Trends in historical annual flows for major rivers
in Alberta. Publication No. T/749. Edmonton Alberta.
[22] Rood S., G.M. Samuelson, J.K. Weber and K.A. Wywrot (2005).
Twentieth-century decline in streamflows from the hydrographic apex
of North America. Journal of Hydrology, 306: 215-233.
[23] Case Roslyn A. and Macdonald, Glen M. (2003). Tree ring
reconstructions of streamflow for three Canadian prairie rivers. Journal
of the American Water Resources Association, 39(3):703-716.
[24] Laird, K.R., B.F. Cumming, S. Wunsam, J.A. Rusak, R.J. Oglesby, S.C.
Fritz and P.R. Leavitt (2003). Lake sediments record large-scale shifts
in moisture regimes across the northern prairies of North America
during the past two millennia. Proceedings of the National Academy of
the Sciences, 100(5): 2483-2488.
[25] Sauchyn, D., J. Stroich, A. Beriault (2003). A paleoclimatic context for
the drought of 1999-2001 in the northern Great Plains of North
America. The Geographic Journal, 169(2): 158-167.
[26] Schindler, D.W. and W. F. Donahue (2006). An impending water crisis
in Canada-s western prairie provinces. Proc. Nat. Academy of the
Sciences,103(19):7210-7216.
[27] Chen, Z., S.E. Grasby, K.G. Osadetz and P. Fesko (2006). Historical
climate and stream flow trends and future demand analysis in the
Calgary region, Canada. Water, Science & Technology, 53(10): 1-11.
[28] Lapp, Suzan, Byrne, James, Townshend Ivan and Kienzle, Stefan
(2005). Climate warming impacts on snowpack accumulation in an
alpine watershed. International Journal of Climatology, 25: 521-536.
[29] Byrne, J. S. Kienzle, D. Johnson, G. Duke, V. Gannon, B. Selinger and
J. Thomas (2006). Current and future water issues in the Oldman River
Basin of Alberta, Canada. Water, Science & Technology, 53(10): 327-
334.
[30] Alberta Environment (2002). South Saskatchewan River Basin Water
Management Plan: Phase One, water allocation transfers. Publication
No. T/661. Edmonton, Alberta.
[31] Alberta Environment (2003). South Saskatchewan River Basin water
management plan phase two: background studies. Publication No.
I/943. Edmonton, Alberta.
[32] Alberta Environment (2002). South Saskatchewan River Basin - Nonirrigation
water use forecast. Hydroconsult and Canadian Resource
Economics Ltd.
[33] Alberta Environment (2006). Approved water management plan for the
South Saskatchewan River Basin (Alberta). Publication No. I/011.
Edmonton, Alberta.
[34] Pentney, A. and D. Ohrn (2008). Navigating from history into the
future: the water management plan for the South Saskatchewan River
Basin in Alberta. Canadian Water Resources Journal 33(4): 381-396.
[35] Richter, Brian D., Mathews, R., Harrison, D.L. and R. Wigington
(2003). Ecologically sustainable water management: managing river
flows for ecological integrity. Ecological Applications, 13(1): 206-224.
[36] Folke, Carl (2003). Freshwater for resilience: a shift in thinking.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B, 358:
2027-2036.
[37] Priscoli, J. (2000). Water and civilization: using history to reframe
water policy debates and to build a new ecological realism. Water
Policy, 1(6): 623-636.
[38] Alberta Environment (2003) Strategic overview of riparian and aquatic
condition of the South Saskatchewan River Basin. Golder Associates,
Calgary.
[39] Falkenmark, M. and C. Folke (2010). Ecohydrosolidarity: a new ethics
for stewarship of value-adding rainfall. In, Water Ethics, Brown, P.G.
and J.J. Schmidt eds. Washington DC: Island Press, pp. 247-264.
[40] Bradford, A. (2008). An ecological flow assessment framework:
building a bridge to implementation in Canada. Canadian Water
Resources Journal 33(3): 215-232.
[41] Alberta Environment (2003). Instream flow needs determination report
for the South Saskatchewan River, Alberta, Canada. Publication No.
T/719. Edmonton, Alberta.
[42] Alberta Environment (2007) Aquatic and riparian condition assessment
of the South Saskatchewan River Basin. Edmonton, Alberta: ISBN 978-
0-7785-6719-6 (online version).
[43] Alberta Environment (2003) South Saskatchewan River Basin water
management plan, Phase 2: Scenario modeling results, Part 1.
Publication No. T/710. Edmonton, Alberta.
[44] Brown, P.G. and Schmidt, J.J. (2010). An ethic of compassionate
retreat. In Water Ethics Brown, P.G. and J.J. Schmidt eds. Washington
DC: Island Press, pp. 265-286.
[45] Schmidt, J.J. (2007). Pricing water to death: Alberta-s water permits
prolong the problem. Alternatives Journal 33: 29-30.
[46] Jakeman, A.J and R.A. Letcher (2003). Integrated assessment and
modeling: features, principles and examples from catchment
management. Environmental modeling and software, 18:491-501.
[47] Dinar, A., K. Kemper, W. Blomquist and P. Kurukulasuriya (2007).
Whitewater: decentralization of river basin water resource management.
Journal of policy modeling, 29(6): 851-867.