The Capacity of Government to Deliver Sustainable and Integrated Transport: The Case of Transit Oriented Development in Perth, Australia

There is a renewed interest in land use transport integration as a means of achieving sustainable accessibility. Such accessibility requires designing more than simply the transport network; it also requires attention to place (built form). Transitoriented development would appear to capture many of the criteria deemed important in land use transport integration. In Perth, Australia, there have been planning policies for the past 20 years requiring transit-oriented development around railway stations throughout the metropolitan area. While the policy intent, particularly at the State level, is clear the implementation of policy has been fairly ineffective. The first part of this paper provides an examination of state and local government planning and transport policies, evaluating them using a set of land use transport integration criteria considered all encompassing. This provides some insight into the extent of state and local government capacity to deliver land use transport integration. The second part of this paper examines the extent of implementation by examining existing and proposed land use around station precincts throughout metropolitan Perth. The findings of this research suggest that the capacity of state and local government to deliver land use transport integration is reasonable in a planning policy sense. Implementation, despite long policy lead times, has been lacking. It appears to be more effective where local planning controls have been suspended with new redevelopment authorities given powers to develop land around railway stations.

• Carey Curtis

• Transit-oriented development
• sustainable transport
• transport policy.

[1] Banister D 2005, 'Overcoming barriers to the implementation of
sustainable transport', in Barriers to Sustainable Transport: institutions,
regulations and sustainability, eds. Reitveld P & Stough R, Spon Press,
Abingdon.
[2] Breheny M, Gurbey A, Strike J 1996, The Compact City and the Need
to Travel: The implementation of UK Planning Policy Guidance in
Jenks M, Burton E & Williams K 1996, The Compact City: A
Sustainable Urban Form?, E & FN Spon, London.
[3] Bressi T W (1994) 'Planning the American Dream', in The New
Urbanism: Toward an Architecture of Community, ed. Katz P, McGraw
Hill, New York.
[4] City of Armadale, 2005, Local Planning Scheme NO.4, City of
Armadale:Perth.
[5] City of Fremantle, 2007, Local Planning Scheme No. 4, City of
Fremantle:Perth.
[6] Town of Kwinana, 1998, Town Planning Scheme No. 2, Town of
Kwinana:Perth.
[7] City of South Perth, 2003, Town Planning Scheme No.6, City of South
Perth:Perth..
[8] Curtis C (2005) The Windscreen World of Land Use Transport Integration:
Experiences from Perth, a Dispersed City. Town Planning Review Vol 76
(4) pp.423-453.
[9] Dittmar H & Ohland G 2004, The New Transit Town: Best practices in
transit-oriented development, Island Press, Washington DC.
[10] (DOTARS) Department of Transport and the Regional Services (2003)
National Charter of Integrated Land Use and Transport Planning,
Department of Transport and the Regions, Canberra.
[11] (EMCT/OECD) European Conference of Transport Ministers &
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 2003,
Implementing Sustainable Urban Travel Policies: National Reviews,
OECD Publications Service, Paris.
[12] Government of Western Australia (2003) Hope for the future: the
Western Australia state sustainability strategy, State Government of
Western Australia, Perth.
[13] Ministry of Transportation and Ministry of Municipal Affairs, 1995,
Transit-Supportive Land Use Planning Guidelines, Ministry for
Transportation and Ministry for Municipal Affairs, Ontario.
[14] North D 1990, Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic
Performance. Cambridge University Press, New York.
[15] Reitveld P & Stough R (eds.) 2005, Barriers to Sustainable Transport:
institutions, regulations and sustainability, Spon Press, Abingdon.
[16] Richardson E 2002, The role of local government in integrated
transport. Proceedings of the Integrated transport for local communities
conference: local solutions to local problems, December 2002,
Melbourne.
[17] Ubbels B and Verhoef E 2005, Barriers to transport pricing, in Barriers
to Sustainable Transport: institutions, regulations and sustainability,
eds. Reitveld P & Stough R, Spon Press, Abingdon.
[18] (WAPC) Western Australian Planning Commission, 1988, Development
Control Policy 1.6 Residential Development near metropolitan railway
stations. WAPC:Perth.
[19] (WAPC) Western Australian Planning Commission, 1999, Development
Control Policy 1.6, Planning to Enhance Public Transport Use,
WAPC:Perth.
[20] (WAPC) Western Australian Planning Commission, 2004, Network
City: Community Planning Strategy for Perth and Peel. WAPC, Perth.
[21] (WAPC) Western Australian Planning Commission, 2006, Development
Control Policy 1.6" Planning to support transit use and transit oriented
development, WAPC:Perth.