Reflections of Prospective Teachers Toward a Critical Thinking-Based Pedagogical Course: A Case Study

Promoting critical thinking (CT) in an educational setting has been appraised in order to enhance learning and intellectual skills. In this study, a pedagogical course in a vocational teacher education program in Turkey was designed by integrating CT skill-based strategies/activities into the course content and CT skills were means leading to intended course objectives. The purpose of the study was to evaluate the importance of the course objectives, the attainment of the objectives, and the effectiveness of teachinglearning strategies/activities from prospective teachers- points of view. The results revealed that although the students mostly considered the course objectives important, they did not feel competent in the attainment of all objectives especially in those related to the main topic of Learning and those requiring higher order thinking skills. On the other hand, the students considered the course activities effective for learning and for the development of thinking skills, especially, in interpreting, comparing, questioning, contrasting, and forming relationships.

Authors:

• Ahmet Ok
• Banu Yücel Toy

Keywords:

• Critical thinking
• critical thinking-based instruction
• higher order thinking skills
• teacher education

References:

[1] O. Ak─▒no─ƒlu, The effect of critical thinking skills based science
education to learning outcomes (Unpublished doctoral dissertation).
Hacettepe University, Turkey, 2001.
[2] B.K. Beyer, "Improving student thinking," The Clearing House, vol. 71
(5), 1998, pp.262-267.
[3] R. Burden, "How can we best help children to become effective
thinkers and learners? The case for and against thinking skills
programmes" in Thinking through the curriculum, R. Burden & M.
Williams, Eds. London: Routledge, 1998, pp.1-27.
[4] R. Burden and M. Williams, Thinking through the curriculum. London:
Routledge, 1998.
[5] K.S. Carr, How can we teach critical thinking? Urbana, IL: ERIC
Clearinghouse on Elementary and Early Childhood Education. (ERIC
Document Reproduction Service No. ED326304), 1990.
[6] K. Celuch and M. Slama, "Teaching critical thinking skills for the 21st
century: An advertising principles case study," Journal of Education for
Business, vol.74 (3), 1999, pp.134-139.
[7] A. L. Costa (Ed.) Developing minds: A resource book for teaching
thinking. Virginia: Association for Supervision and Curriculum
Development, 1991.
[8] L.K. Doebler, T.G. Roberson, and C.W. Ponder, "Preservice teacher
case study responses: A preliminary attempt to describe program
impact," Education, vol.119 (2), 1998, pp.349-358.
[9] P.D. Eggen and D. Kauchak Strategies for teachers: Teaching content
and thinking skills, 4th ed. Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 2001.
[10] R. Z. Elias, "Anti-intellectual attitudes and academic self-efficacy
among Business students," Journal of Education for Business,
vol.84(2), 2008, pp.110-117
[11] R. Fisher, Teaching thinking: Philosophical enquiry in the classroom,
2nd ed. London: Continuum, 2003.
[12] A. Harrigan and V. Vincenti, "Developing higher-order thinking
through an intercultural assignment," College Teaching, vol.52(3),
2004, pp.113-120.
[13] H.L. Harrington and J.W. Garrison, "Cases as shared inquiry: A
dialogical model of teacher preparation," American Educational
Research Journal, vol.29(4), 1992, pp.715-735.
[14] D.L. Hatcher, "Stand-alone versus integrated critical thinking courses,"
The Journal of General Education, vol.55 (3-4), 2006, pp.247-272.
[15] R. Heitzmann, "Case study instruction in teacher education:
Opportunity to develop students' critical thinking, school smarts and
decision making," Education, vol.128(4), 2008, pp.523-542.
[16] W. Hughes and J. Lavery, Critical thinking: An introduction to the
basic skills. Canada: Broadview Press, 2004.
[17] M. Kirkwood, "Infusing higher-order thinking and learning to learn
into content instruction: A case study of secondary computing studies
in Scotland," Journal of Curriculum Studies, vol.32 (4), 2000, pp.509-
535.
[18] D. Kökdemir, Decision making and problem solving under uncertainty
(Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Ankara University, Turkey, 2003.
[19] J.C. Kunselman and K.A. Johnson, "Using the case method to facilitate
learning," College Teaching, vol.52 (3), 2004, pp.87-92.
[20] S.A. McDade, "Case study pedagogy to advance critical thinking,"
Teaching of Psychology, vol.22 (1), 1995, pp.9-10.
[21] J. McTighe and J. Schollenberger, "Why teach thinking? A statement of
rationale" in Developing minds: A resource book for teaching thinking
A. L. Costa, Ed. Virginia: Association for Supervision and Curriculum
Development, 1991, pp.2-5.
[22] D. Moseley, J. Elliot, M. Gregson, and S. Higgins, "Thinking skills
frameworks for use in education and training," British Educational
Research Journal, vol.31(3), 2005, pp. 367-390.
[23] R. Nickerson, "Thoughts on teaching thinking," Educational
Leadership, vol.39 (1), 1981, pp.21-24.
[24] J. Nisbet, "The thinking curriculum," Educational Psychology, vol.13
(3/4), 1993, pp. 281-210.
[25] R. Paul and L. Elder, Critical thinking: Tools for taking charge of your
learning and your life. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall,
2006.
[26] R. Paul, A.J.A. Binker, D. Martin, and K. Adamson, Critical thinking
handbook: High school. Sonoma State University: Center for Critical
Thinking and Moral Critique, 1989.
[27] B. Potts, Strategies for teaching critical thinking. Washington DC:
Clearinghouse on Assessment and Evaluation. (ERIC Document
Reproduction Service No. ED385606), 1994.
[28] L.E. Raths, A. Jonas, A. Rothstein, and S. Wassermann, Teaching for
thinking: Theory and application. Columbus, OH: Charles E. Merrill
Publishing Company, 1967.
[29] J.H. Reed and J.D. Kromrey, "Teaching critical thinking in a
community college history course: Empirical evidence from infusing
Paul's model," College Student Journal, vol.35 (2), 2001, pp. 201-215.
[30] Ç. Semerci, "Eleştirel Düşünme Becerilerinin Geliştirilmesi
[Developing Critical Thinking Skills]," E─ƒitim ve Bilim, vol. 28(127),
2003, pp. 64-70.
[31] N. Semerci "The effect of thinking on the development of criticizing
ability in micro teaching lesson (The example of Technical Education
Faculty of University of F─▒rat)" (Unpublished doctoral dissertation).
F─▒rat University, Turkey, 1999.
[32] T. Solon, "Generic critical thinking infusion and course content
learning in Introductory Psychology," Journal of Instructional
Psychology, vol.34 (2), 2007, pp.95-109.
[33] E.F. Sparapani, "The effect of teaching for higher-level thinking: An
analysis of teacher reactions," Education, vol.121 (1), 2000, pp.80-89.
[34] R.J. Swartz, S.D. Fischer, and S. Parks Infusing the teaching of critical
and creative thinking into secondary science: A lesson design
handbook. Pacific Grove, CA: Critical Thinking Books and Software,
1998.
[35] S. ┼×ahinel, Developing integrated language skills via critical thinking
skills (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Hacettepe University,
Turkey, 2001.
[36] A. Zohar and Y.J. Dori, "Higher order thinking skills and lowachieving
students: Are they mutually exclusive?" The Journal of the
Learning Sciences, vol.12(2), 2003, pp.145-181.