Re-Engineering the Human: New Reproductive Technologies and the Specter of Frankenstein

The virulent debates that have dogged research on, and the diffusion of, a wide range of technologies indicate a growing loss of confidence in what we might call, the techno-scientific endeavour to reshape the world. Utopian images of a world rendered ever more amenable to human desires are now closely shadowed by just as compelling dystopian visions of monstrosity and disaster that are nevertheless constructed from the same cultural material. The paper uses the case of the debates over developments in reproductive technology to offer some observations on the ways in which such technologies routinely become enmirred in cultural ambivalence.

Authors:

• Brian P. Bloomfield
• Theo Vurdubakis

Keywords:

• Culture
• media
• new reproductive technologies
• society.

References:

[1] Daily Express (2000) ÔÇÿCult in First Bid to Clone Human-, October 11: 1
& 4-5.
[2] The Daily Mail (1996) ÔÇÿA little miracle of science-, 19 January: 1.
[3] The Daily Mail (2002) ÔÇÿBaby clone or big con?-, 28 December: 1-5.
[4] The Daily Mirror (1994) ÔÇÿPlaying God With Babies-, 10 January: 7.
[5] The Daily Telegraph (1995) ÔÇÿHypothetical Babies-, Editorial, June 2.
[6] The Daily Telegraph (2002) ÔÇÿAttack of the clones-, 30 December,
Editorial.
[7] Douglas, M. (1966) Purity and Danger (London: Routledge).
[8] Dronamraju, K. R. (ed.) (1995) Haldane-s Daedalus Revisited (Oxford:
Oxford University Press).
[9] Durkheim, E. (1948) Elementary Forms of the Religious Life (Glencoe:
Free Press).
[10] Edwards, J.; Franklin, S.; Hirsch, E.; Price, F. and Strathern, M. (eds)
(1993) Technologies of Procreation: Kinship in the Age of Assisted
Conception (Manchester: ManchesterUniversity Press).
[11] Franklin, S. (1990) "Deconstructing ÔÇÿDesperateness-", in M. McNeil, I.
Varcoe, and S. Yearley (eds.) The New Reproductive Technologies,
(London: Macmillan).
[12] Franklin, S. (1997) Embodied Progress: a cultural account of assisted
conception (London: Routledge).
[13] Habgood, J. (1994) ÔÇÿWhere Should Babies Come From?- The
Independent, January 12.
[14] Haldane, J. B. S, (1924) Daedalus, or Science and the Future (New
York: Dutton and Co.).
[15] Hirsch, E. (1993) ÔÇÿNegotiated Limits: Interviews in South East England-,
in J. Edwards; S. Franklin; E. Hirsch; F. Price; & M. Strathern (eds)
Technologies of Procreation: Kinship in the Age of Assisted Conception
(Manchester: University Press), 67-95.
[16] Hogkinson, N. (1994) ÔÇÿThe Master Race: Designer Babies-, Sunday
Times, January 2.
[17] The Independent (1994) ÔÇÿLet Britain lead on genetic debate-, comment, 8
January.
[18] The Independent (2003) ÔÇÿThree more clones to be born say Raelians-, 6
January, 2.
[19] Jaenisch, R. and Wilmut, I. (2001) ÔÇÿDon-t Clone Humans- Science
291(5513): 2552.
[20] Lightfoot, L. (1994) ÔÇÿInfertility Doctors Plan to Use Eggs from Aborted
Foetuses-, The Sunday Times, 2 January.
[21] Lyon, J. and Gorner, P. (1995) Altered Fates, Gene Therapy and the
Retooling of Human Life (London: W. H. Norton & Co.).
[22] Mulkay, M. (1997) The Embryo Research Debate: Science and the
Politics of Reproduction (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
[23] Newsweek (1994) ÔÇÿHow Far Should We Push Mother Nature?- January
17: 43.
[24] Oddie, W. (1994) ÔÇÿHow to tell Frankenstein the yuk stops here-, The
Sunday Times, 9 January: 4-5.
[25] Ross, A. (1997) ÔÇÿDr Frankenstein I Presume?- available at
http://www.salon.com/feb97/news/news970224.html.
[26] Russell, B. (1924) Icarus or the Future of Science (New York: Dutton
and Co.).
[27] Shelley, M. (1992, orig, 1818) Frankenstein; or the modern Prometheus
(Harmondsworth: Penguin).
[28] Silver, L. M. (1998) Remaking Eden: Cloning and Beyond in a Brave
New World, (New York, Weidenfield & Nicolson).
[29] Squier, S. M. (1995) Babies in bottles: Twentieth Century Visions of
Reproductive Technology, (New Jersey: Rutgers University Press).
[30] Strathern, M. (1992) After Nature (Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press).
[31] Time (1997) ÔÇÿA special report on cloning-, 10 March.
[32] The Times (2003) ÔÇÿUFO cult breaks promise to prove Eve was cloned-, 4
January, 4.
[33] Toffler, A. (1971) Future Shock (London: Pan).
[34] Turney, J. (1998) Frankenstein-s Footsteps (London: Yale University
Press).
[35] Weatherall, D. J. (1995) ÔÇÿDaedalus, Haldane and Medical Science-, in
Dronamraju, K. R. (ed.) Haldane-s Daedalus Revisited (Oxford: Oxford
University Press).
[36] Wilmut, I, Cambell, K. and Tudge, C. (2000) The Second Creation: The
Age of Biological Control by the Scientists Who Cloned Dolly (London:
Headline).