Indirect Solar Desalination: Value Engineering and Cost Benefit Analysis

This study examines the feasibility of indirect solar desalination in oil producing countries in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. It relies on value engineering (VE) and costbenefit with sensitivity analyses to identify optimal coupling configurations of desalination and solar energy technologies. A comparative return on investment was assessed as a function of water costs for varied plant capacities (25,000 to 75,000 m3/day), project lifetimes (15 to 25 years), and discount rates (5 to 15%) taking into consideration water and energy subsidies, land cost as well as environmental externalities in the form of carbon credit related to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction. The results showed reverse osmosis (RO) coupled with photovoltaic technologies (PVs) as the most promising configuration, robust across different prices for Brent oil, discount rates, as well as different project lifetimes. Environmental externalities and subsidies analysis revealed that a 16% reduction in existing subsidy on water tariffs would ensure economic viability. Additionally, while land costs affect investment attractiveness, the viability of RO coupled with PV remains possible for a land purchase cost <$ 80/m2 or a lease rate <$1/m2/yr. Beyond those rates, further subsidy lifting is required.

Authors:

• Grace Rachid
• Mutasem El-Fadel
• Mahmoud Al-Hindi
• Ibrahim Jamali
• Daniel Abdel Nour

Keywords:

• Solar energy
• desalination
• value engineering
• CBA
• carbon credit
• subsidies.

References:

[1] Palenzuela, P., Zaragoza, G., Alarcon, D., Blanco, J., 2011. Simulation
and Evaluation of the coupling of coupling of desalination units to
parabolic trough solar power plants in the Mediterranean Region,
Desalination, 281, 379 – 397
[2] El-Ghonemy, A.M.K., 2012. Water desalination systems powered by
renewable energy sources: Review, Renew. Sustain. Rev., 16, 1537-
1556
[3] Ghaffour, N., Missimer, T., Amy, G.L., 2013.Technical review and
evaluation of the economics of water desalination: Current and future
challenges for better water supply sustainability. Desalination, 309, 197-
207
[4] Shannon, M.A., Bohn, P.A., Elimelech, M., Georgiadis, J.G., Mariñas,
B.J., Mayes, A.M.Science and technology for water purification in the
coming decades, Nature 2008, 452, 301–310.
[5] Trieb, F., 2007. Concentrating solar power for seawater desalination,
Aqua-CSP Study report, German Aerospace Center, Stuttgart, Germany
[6] Zhou, Y., Tol, R.S.J., 2005. Evaluating the costs of desalination and
water transport, Water Resour. Res. 41 (W03003), 1–10.
[7] Greenlee, L.F., Lawler, D.F., Freeman, B.D., Marrot, B., Moulin, P.,
2009. Reverse osmosis desalination: water sources, technology, and
today´s challenges: a review, Water Res. 43, 2317–2348.
[8] Shatat, M., Worall, M., Riffat, S., 2013. Opportunities for solarwater
desalination worldwide: a review. Sustain. Cities Soc., 9, 67 - 80
[9] Blanco, J., Alarcón-Padilla, D.C., Zaragoza, G., Palenzuela, P., Guillén,
E., Ibarra, M., 2011. Solar energy and desalination processes: status and
development perspective, Water Desalination Conference in the Arab
Countries (ARWADEX), April 17–20 2011, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
[10] Quteishat, K., Abu-Arabi, A., 2012. Promotion of solar desalination in
the MENA region,Middle East Desalination Research Center, Muscat,
Oman. (Online) Available at: http://shebacss.com/rd/docs/rdresrs003.pdf
(2012 20-9))
[11] Webber, M.E., 2008. Catch-22: Water vs. Energy, Sci. Am. 18, 34–41.
[12] Al-Karaghouli, A., Rene, D., Kazmerski, L., 2009. Solar and wind
opportunities for water desalination in the Arab region, Renew. Sustain.
Energy Rev., 13, 2397 – 2407.
[13] Arabian Oil and Gas, 2009. New Kid on the Grid, Utilities ME. (Online)
Available at: http://www.arabianoilandgas.com/article-5132-
new_kid_on_the_grid/ (2012 11-11)
[14] Nat. Geo. 2009. Solar Power: Endless Potential, National Geographic,
(Online) Available at: http://www.ngm,com (2012 19-05)
[15] Rizzuti, L., Ettouney, H., Cipolina A., (eds.) 2006. Solar Desalination
for the 21st Century. Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research
Workshop on Solar Desalination for the 21st Century, Hammamet,
Tunisia, 23-25 February 2006; Series: Nato Security through Science
Series C: 355–369. 2007
[16] Younos, T., Tulou, K., 2005. Energy Needs, Consumption and Sources,
J. Contemp. Water Res. Educ., 132, 27-38. [17] Lamei, A., Van der Zaag, P., Von Munch, E., 2008. Impact of solar
energy cost on water production cost of seawater desalination plants in
Egypt, Energy Policy, 36, 1748 - 1756
[18] Moser, M., Trieb, F., Fichter, T., Kern, J., 2013. Renewable
desalination: a methodology for cost comparison, Desalination Water
Treat., 51, 4-6
[19] Fiorenza, G., Sharma, V.K., Braccio, G., 2003. Techno-economic
evaluation of a solar powered water desalination plant,
Ener.Conserv.Manag. 44, 2217–2240.
[20] Karagiannis, I., Soldatos, P., 2008. Water desalination cost literature:
review and assessment, Desalination, 223, 448-456.
[21] Blanco, J., Alarcon, D., 2003. Innovative Ideas to reduce current cost of
solar seawater desalination based on MED Technology, Centro de
InvestigacionesEnergeticas, Medioambientales y Technologicas
(CIEMAT)
[22] Thomson, M., 2003. Reverse Osmosis Desalination of Seawater
Powered by Photovoltaics without batteries, Thesis, UK: Loughborough
University
[23] Fritzmann, C., Lowenberg, G., Wintgens, T., Melin, T., 2007.State –ofthe-
art of reverse osmosis desalination, Desalination, 216, 1-76.
[24] Nisan, S., Benzarti, N., 2008. A comprehensive economic evaluation of
integrated desalination systems using fossil fuelled and nuclear energies
and including their environmental costs, Desalination, 229, 125-146.
[25] Trieb, F., Nitsch, J., Kronshage, S., Schillings, C., Brischke, L., Knies,
G., Czisch, G., 2008. Concentrating solar power for seawater
desalination in the Middle East and North Africa, Desalination, 220,
165–183.
[26] DLR, Direktnormalstrahlungfür das Jahr, 2005. German Aerospace
Center DLR, Institute of Technical Thermodynamics, Dep. Systems
Analysis & Technology Assessment, Stuttgart
[27] Cameron, P., Crompton, G., 2009. Solar Power Plant Pre-feasibility
Study.ActewAGL and ACT Government. Parsons Brinckerhoff
Australia Pty Limited, Australia, (Online) Available at:
http://www.environment.act.gov.au/_data/assets/pdf_file/0019/154054/S
olar_Power_plant_Pre-feasibility_study.pdf (2012 21-2)
[28] Florio, M., Finzi, U., Genco, M., Levarlet, F., Maffii, S., Tracogna, A.,
2008. Guide to cost benefit analysis of investment projects, Directorate
General Regional Policy, European Commission. (Online) Available at:
http://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/sources/docgener/guides/cost/guide2
008_en.pdf (2012 12-5)
[29] Olwig, R., Hirsch, T., Sattler, C., Glade, H., Schmeken, L., Will, S.,
Ghermandi, A., Messalem, R., 2012. Techno–economic analysis of
combined concentrating solar power and desalination plant
configurations, Desalination and Water Treatment, 41(1-3), 9-25.
[30] Reddy, K.V., Ghaffour, N., 2007. Overview of the cost of desalinated
water and costing methodologies, Desalination, 205, 340-353.
[31] Sargent & Lundy LLC Consulting Group, 2004. Assessment of
Parabolic Trough & Power tower Solar Technology, National
Renewable Energy Laboratory, San Diego Regional Renewable Energy
Study Goup, Colorado
[32] Younos, T., 2005. The Economics of Desalination, J. Contemp. Water
Res. Educ., 132, 39-45.
[33] Levy, H., Sarnat, M., 1994. Capital Investment and Financial Decisions,
5th Edition, United Kingdom: Prentice Hall International
[34] Fthenakis, V.M, Kim, H.C., 2007. Greenhouse-gas emissions from solar
electric- and nuclear power: A life-cycle study, Energy Policy, 35, 2549-
2557.
[35] McIntyre, J., Berg, B., Seto, H., Borchardt, S., 2011. Comparison of
Lifecycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Various Electricity Generation
Sources, World Nuclear Association, UK. (Online) Available at:
http://www.worldnuclear.org/uploadedfiles/org/reference/pdf/compariso
n_of_lifecycle.pdf (2012 20-11)