Competitive Advantage Challenges Affecting the Apparel Manufacturing Industry of South Africa (AMISA): Application of Porter’s Factor Conditions

This paper applied factor conditions from Porter’s Diamond Model (1990) to understand the various challenges facing the AMISA. Factor conditions highlighted in Porter’s model are grouped into two groups namely, basic and advance factors. Two AMISA associations representing over 10 000 employees were interviewed. The largest Clothing, Textiles and Leather (CTL) apparel retail group was also interviewed with a government department implementing the industrialization policy were interviewed. The paper points out that AMISA have basic factor conditions necessary for competitive advantage in the apparel industries. However advance factor creation has proven to be a challenge for AMISA, Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) and government. Poor infrastructural maintenance has contributed to high manufacturing costs and poor quick response technologies. The use of Porter’s Factor Conditions as a tool to analyze the sector’s competitive advantage challenges and opportunities has increased knowledge regarding factors that limit the AMISA’s competitiveness. It is therefore argued that other studies on Porter’s Diamond model factors like Demand conditions, Firm strategy, structure and rivalry and Related and supporting industries can be used to analyze the situation of the AMISA for the purposes of improving competitive advantage.

Authors:

• S. Mbatha
• A. Mastamet-Mason

Keywords:

• Compliance rule
• apparel manufacturing industry
• factor conditions
• advance skills.

References:

[1] African trade, infrastructure key: Zuma. (Online), Available from:
http://www.southafrica.info/africa/zuma-300112.htm#ixzz1nQrQcy00.
(Accessed: 20/04/2013).
[2] J. Barnes, A strategic assessment of the South African clothing sector.
Presented at the Presidency/ComMark Sector Workshop on the 26th of
November 2004. 2005.
[3] L. Biyase, The Future Lies in Africa, Say SA’s Builders. Sunday Time.
2011. Nov. 13.p:5
[4] R. Burger, & R. Jafta, Affirmative action in South Africa: an empirical
assessment of the impact on labour market outcomes. Centre for
research on Inequality, human security and ethnicity. 2010. [5] Climate change: Africa’s Catch – 22. Sunday Times, 2011. November.
13. p. 9.
[6] B. Coka, 2013. Productivity and Transport. Sunday Times, October.
27:19.
[7] S. Das, Quality Issues Related t Apparel Merchandising in South Africa.
M.Sc. Thesis, Port Elizabeth, Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University.
2011.
[8] K. Davie, Short Back and Sides, Please. Mail & guardian. 2012. Feb. 24.
p.7.
[9] Deliotte. Enhancing Manufacturing Competitive in South Africa.
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited (DTTL) PTY LTD. 2013.
[10] L. Donnelly, Patel Cracks the Whip. Mail & Guardian, 2012. February
17-23. p.2.
[11] L. Donnelly, Call for Industrial Sector to Save Energy. Mail &
Guardian, 2013. February 22-28.p.7.
[12] FDI into Africa on the increase: survey (Online), Available from:
http://www.southafrica.info/africa/fdi-250511b.htm#.VW_pi8-qqko.
(Accessed: 20/09/2014). 2011.
[13] Ibrahim Index of African Governance. Mail & guardian, 2011. October.
14-20.p.27.
[14] B. Jin, “The Diamond Approach to the Competitiveness of Korea’s
Apparel Industry.” Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management,
2006. 10 (2). pp.195-208.
[15] B. Jin, & H. Moon, The Diamond Approach to the Competitiveness of
Korea’s Apparel Industry: Porter and Beyond. Journal of Fashion
Marketing and Management, 2006. 10 (2). pp. 195-208.
[16] R. Kaplinsky, & M. Morris, Trade Policy Reform and Competitive
Response in Kwa-Zulu Natal Province, South Africa. Elsevier science
LTD, 1999. 27 (4).pp. 717-737.
[17] M. Knappe, Exporting Textiles & Clothing: What’s the Cost for LDCs?
International trade centre, International trade forum. 2005. 1.
[18] E. K. Ko, D. Kincade, & J. R. Brown, Impact of Business Type upon the
Adoption of Quick Response Technologies. International Journal of
Operations & Production management, 2000. 20(9).pp.1093-1111.
[19] D. Macfarlane, Education’s political nettles. Mail & guardian,
November, 2011. 18-24.p.43.
[20] M. Mann, & S. Byun, Accessing Opportunities in Apparel Retail Sectors
in India: Porter’s Diamond approach. Journal of Fashion Marketing and
Management, 2011. 15 (2).pp. 194-210.
[21] T. Mashego, Malema is “Sinking FDI Ship”. Sunday Times, October.
2011. 16.p.3.
[22] S. Mbatha, Development of Competitive Advantage for Apparel
Manufacturing Industries of South Africa. M-Tech Fashion.
Dissertation. Pretoria. Tshwane University of Technology. 2014.
[23] M. Mbeki, Architects of Poverty. Picador Africa Publishers. 2009.
[24] A. Mcree, & N.L. Cassill, Sub-Saharan Africa: Potential production
source for Textiles and Apparel? Journal of Textile and Apparel,
Technology and Management. 2002. 2(3).
[25] O. Miruka, No need to Throw in the Towel yet: The Case of the Revival
of South African Textiles and Clothing Industry. Mediterranean Journal
of Social sciences, 2014. 5(7).pp. 11-24.
[26] Mo Ibrahim Foundation. 2011 Ibrahim Index of African Governance
Summary. 2011.
[27] P. Mohr, L. Fourie & Associates. Economics for South African Students,
4th Ed. Pretoria: Van Schaik Publishers. 2008.
[28] M. Morris, & J. Barnes, The Challenges to Reversing the Decline of the
Apparel Sector in South Africa. International Conference on
Manufacturing-Led Growth for Employment and Equality in South
Africa. Johannesburg, South Africa. 2014.
[29] N. Nattrass, & J. Seekings, Job destruction in the South African Clothing
industry: How an Unholy Alliance of Organised Labour, The State and
Some Firms is Undermining Labour-Intensive Growth. Centre for social
science research. 2013. P.323.
[30] S. Ndlangisa, Economically Active Population Breakdown by Race and
Gender (2010). City Press. August. 2011. 7.p.10.
[31] S. Nip, Export Marketing Trend for Textile and Apparel Industry in
South Africa. MBA Thesis. University of KwaZulu Natal: UKZN Press.
2004.
[32] T. Oxford, Freighting South Africa’s Future. Mail & Guardian, October.
2013. 4-10.p. 6.
[33] M.E. Porter, Competitive Strategy. New York: The Free Press. 1990.
[34] M.E. Porter, & C. H. Ketels, UK Competitiveness: Moving to the Next
Stage. Economic & Social Research Council in May 2003. 2003.
[35] J. Sey, Changes Could Smooth the Way. Mail & Guardian, October
2013. 4-10.p.1.
[36] South Africa. Department of Trade and Industry. Industrial Policy
Action Plan 2010/11 – 2013/14. Pretoria: Government Printer. 2010.
[37] South Africa. Department of Trade and Industry. Industrial Policy
Action Plan 2014/15 – 2016/17. Pretoria: Government Printer. 2014.
[38] The Textile and Clothing Core Team. Textiles and Clothing Sector.
2005.
[39] E. Van Der Merwe, Telkom mired in static. Mail & Guardian, October
2011. 14-20.p.16.
[40] World Economic Forum. The Africa Competitiveness Report. (Online).
http://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Publications/Af
rica%20Competitiveness%20Report%202009.pdf (Accessed:
26/03/2012). 2009.
[41] World Economic Forum. The Africa Competitiveness Report. (Online).
http://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Publications/Af
rica%20Competitiveness%20Report%202011.pdf (Accessed:
26/03/2012). 2011.
[42] World Economic Forum. The Africa Competitiveness Report. (Online).
http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Africa_Competitiveness_Report_
2013.pdf (Accessed: 20/11/2013). 2013.
[43] C. Yelland, Gigaba’s Power-Station Stalemate. Mail & Guardian, July
2013. 12-18.p.16.
[44] W. Yu, What Makes a Fashion Design Curriculum Successful? Institute
of textiles and clothing Hong Kong Polytechnic University. 2013. pp.1-
11.