Collocation Errors in English as Second Language (ESL) Essay Writing

In language learning, second language learners as well
as Native speakers commit errors in their attempt to achieve
competence in the target language. The realm of collocation has to do
with meaning relation between lexical items. In all human language,
there is a kind of ‘natural order’ in which words are arranged or relate
to one another in sentences so much so that when a word occurs in a
given context, the related or naturally co-occurring word will
automatically come to the mind. It becomes an error, therefore, if
students inappropriately pair or arrange such ‘naturally’ co–occurring
lexical items in a text. It has been observed that most of the second
language learners in this research group commit collocation errors. A
study of this kind is very significant as it gives insight into the kinds
of errors committed by learners. This will help the language teacher
to be able to identify the sources and causes of such errors as well as
correct them thereby guiding, helping and leading the learners
towards achieving some level of competence in the language. The
aim of the study is to understand the nature of these errors as
stumbling blocks to effective essay writing. The objective of the
study is to identify the errors, analyze their structural compositions so
as to determine whether there are similarities between students in this
regard and to find out whether there are patterns to these kinds of
errors which will enable the researcher to understand their sources
and causes. As a descriptive research, the researcher samples some
nine hundred essays collected from three hundred undergraduate
learners of English as a second language in the Federal College of
Education, Kano, North- West Nigeria, i.e. three essays per each
student. The essays which were given on three different lecture times
were of similar thematic preoccupations (i.e. same topics) and length
(i.e. same number of words). The essays were written during the
lecture hour at three different lecture occasions. The errors were
identified in a systematic manner whereby errors so identified were
recorded only once even if they occur severally in students’ essays.
The data was collated using percentages in which the identified
numbers of occurrences were converted accordingly in percentages.
The findings from the study indicate that there are similarities as well
as regular and repeated errors which provided a pattern. Based on the
pattern identified, the conclusion is that students’ collocation errors
are attributable to poor teaching and learning which resulted in wrong
generalization of rules.

• Fatima Muhammad Shitu

• Collocations
• errors
• collocation errors
• second language learning.

[1] N.S. Abdu - Ridha, & A.A. Al- Riyadh, “Lexical Collocation Errors in
the Writings of Iraqi EFL Learners’’ in Journal of College of Arts.
University of Basra, No (58).2011
[2] A.A. Akbar, “Fixed expressions in written text: Implication for assessing
sophistication. East Lancing, MI: National Center for Research on
Teacher Learning. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED
352808), 1990
[3] J. Bahns, & M. Eldaw, “Should we teach EFL students collocations?’’
System, 21(1), 101-114.1993
[4] J. Bahns, “Lexical collocations: A contrastive view’’, ELT Journal,
47(1), 56-63 1993
[5] M. Benson, E. Benson, & R. Elson, The BBI dictionary of English word
combinations, Amsterdam: John Benjamins.1997
[6] D. Bisk-up, “L1 influences on learners rendering of English
collocations: A Polish/German empirical study.’’ in Vocabulary and
applied linguistics, P. Arnaud, & B. Joint Eds. London: Macmillan
Academic and Professional Ltd., 1992, pp.85-101
[7] S. Boonyasaquan, “an analysis of collocation violations in translation’’
in Journal of Humanities, 27, Bangkok: Faculty of Humanity,
Srinakharinwirot University, 2006, 79-91.
[8] D.F. Brown, ”Advanced vocabulary teaching: problem of collocation in
RELC Journal, 5, 1974, 1-11
[9] J. Chanel, ‘’Applying Semantic Theory into vocabulary teaching in ELT
Journal, 35(1), 1981, 115-122
[10] P.C.Chen, ‘’A corpus- based study of the collocation errors in the
writings of the EFL learners in Taiwan. Unpublished
[11] T. Deveci, ‘’Why and How to teach Collocations? English Teaching
Forum On line Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs.
(http://exchanges.State.gov/forum.Vol5/Vol42/No2/p16.htm) 2004
[12] P. Durrant& N. Schmitt, ‘’To what extent do native and non- native
writer make use of collocations?’’ in IRAL, 47, 2009, 157-177
[13] R. Ellis, the Study of Second Language Acquisition. Oxford: Oxford
University Press, .2008
[14] N.C. Ellis, Memory for Language in Cognition and Second Language
instruction, P. Robinson Ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
2001, pp.33-68.
[15] M. Fan, ‘’an exploratory study of collocation use by ESL students - A
task based approach in System, 37, 2009, 110-123.
[16] M. Farghal and H. Obiedat, ‘’Collocations: A neglected variable in
EFL’’ in International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language
teaching, 33(4), 1995, 315 -531.
[17] J. R. Firth, Papers in Linguistics, 1934-1951. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 1957
[18] C. Gitsaki ,Second lexical language acquisition: a study of development
of collocation knowledge, Maryland: International Scholars Publications,
1997 [19] S. Granger, ‘’Prefabricated patterns in advanced EFL writing:
Collocations and formulae’’ in Phraseology: Theory, analysis and
applications, A. Cowie Ed. Oxford: Oxford University, 1998, pp145-160
[20] S. Granger, M. Pequot, and P. Rayson, ‘’Extraction of multi - word units
from EFL and native English corpora, The Phraseology of the verb
‘make’, in Phraseology in motion I: Methoden und Kritik(Basel 2004),
A. Hacki Buhofer, and H. Burger, Eds. Baltmannsweiler: Schneider
Verlag Hohengehren, 2006, pp57-68
[21] M.A.K. Holliday, & R. Hassan, Cohesion in English. London: Longman,
1976.
[22] M. Hashemi, M. Azizinehad, & S. Dravishi, ‘’The investigation of
collocation errors in university students’ writing majoring in English in
Procedia- Social and Behavioral Sciences 2012, 31,pp555-558
[23] J. Hill, ‘’Re-visiting priorities: From grammatical failure to collocation
success’’ in. Teaching Collocation: Further development in the lexical
approach, M. Lewis, Ed. London: Commercial Color Press Plc, .2000,
47-69
[24] J .E. Horney, ‘’an error analysis of English composition written by
Taiwanese students. Unpublished
[25] P. Howarth, ‘’Phraseology and second language proficiency. ‘Applied
Linguistics, 19, 1998, 45-72.
[26] J. Hsu, & C. Chiu, ‘’.Lexical Collocation and their Relation to Speaking
Proficiency of College EFL Learners in Taiwan in Asian EFL Journal,
Volume 10, Issue 1, Article 9, 2008, pp 181-204,
[27] J. Hsu, ‘’Development of collocation proficiency’’ in Workshop on
English for general business purposes for Taiwanese college students:
Unpublished.
[28] J.T. Hsu, ‘’The effects of collocation instruction on the reading
comprehension and vocabulary learning of Taiwanese college English
majors in The Asian EFL Journal, 12,1, 2010,47-87
[29] L. Huang, ‘’Knowledge of English collocations: An analysis of
Taiwanese EFL learners.’’ (Online) Available:
www.utexasss.edu/students/fleas/tpfle/contents7.doc
[30] T. Koya, ‘’A study of collocations in English and Japanese noun-verb
combinations’’ in Intercultural Communication Studies, XII-1, 2003,
125-145
[31] M. Lewis, Teaching collocation: Further development in the lexical
approach. London: Commercial Color Press, 2000
[32] C.C. Li, ‘’A study of Collocation Error Types in ESL/EFL College
Learners ‘Writing. Unpublished
[33] H.Y. Lien, ‘’the effects of collocation instruction on reading
comprehension of Taiwanese college students. Unpublished
[34] C.P. Liu, ‘’an Analysis of Collocation Errors in EFL Writings in The
Proceeding of the English International Symposium on English
Teaching. Taipei: Crane Publishing Co., Ltd, 1999b,pp,483-494
[35] L.E. Liu, ‘’A corpus based lexical semantic investigation of verb –noun
mis-collocations in Taiwan learners English.’’ Unpublished
[36] A. Mahmood, ‘’Collocation Errors Made by Arab Learners of English’’
in Asian EFL Journal: English Language Teaching and Research
Articles, Article 2, August 2005, pp 1-9.
[37] M. Martynska, ‘’Do English Language Learners Know Collocations?’’
in Investigationes Linguisticae, Vol., XI, Poznan, December 2004, pp1-
11
[38] M. McCarthy, & F. O’Dell, English Collocation in Use. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2005.
[39] A. Mongkolchai, ‘’A study of university students’ ability in using
English collocations, ‘Unpublished.
[40] I.S.P. Nation, Teaching and Learning Vocabulary. Boston: Henley &
Henley, 1990.
[41] J.R. Nattinger& J.S. DeCarrico, Lexical phrases and language teaching.
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992
[42] J.R. Nattinger, ‘’A lexical phrase grammar for ESL’’ in TESOL
Quarterly, 14, 3, 1980,pp 337-344.
[43] J.R. Nattinger, ‘’some current trends in vocabulary teaching.’’ in M. J
.McCarthy, & R.A. Carter Eds. Vocabulary and Language teaching.
New York: Longman, 1988, pp 62-82.
[44] N. Nesselhauf, ‘’the use of collocations by advanced learners of English
and some implications for teaching.’’ Applied Linguistics, 24, 2, 2003,
pp 223-242.
[45] N. Nesselhauf, Collocations in a learner corpus. Amsterdam: John
Benjamin, 2005.
[46] Oxford Collocation Dictionary for Students of English, 2nd Ed. Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2009
[47] S. Phoocharoensil, ‘’Collocation errors in EFL learners’ inter language’’
in Journal of Education and Practice, 2, 3, 2011, pp 103-120
[48] S. Phooncharoensil, ‘’A corpus – based study of English synonyms.’’ in
International Journal of Arts and Sciences, 3, 10, 2010, pp 227-245
[49] R. Shih, ‘’Collocation deficiency in a learner corpus of English from an
overuse perspective’’ in the Proceedings of 14th Pacific Asia Conference
on Language, Information and Computation, 2000, 281-288.
[50] J. Sinclair, Corpus Concordance Collocation. Oxford: OUP, 1991
[51] J. Sinclair, S. Jones, & R. Daley, “English collocation studies’’: The
OSTI report. London: Continuum, 2004
[52] R. Taiwo, ‘’Helping ESL Learners to Minimize Collocation Errors.’’ in
the internet TESL Journal, Vol. X, No 4, April, 2004, pp 1-5.
[53] B. Tang, ‘’Collocation Errors in the Intermediate EFL Learners Inter
language. Sino – US English Teaching,’’ ISSN 1539-1, 12, Dec- 2004,
pp 39-47.
[54] The Collins COBUILD Advanced Learner’s of English Language
Dictionary. Harper Collins Publishers, 2003
[55] Y. Wang, & P. Shaw, ‘’Transfer and universality: Collocation use in
advanced Chinese and Swedish learner English’’ in ICAME JOURNAL:
Computers in English linguistics, 32, 2008, pp 201-232
[56] G. Woolard, ‘’Collocation – encouraging learner independence’’ in
teaching collocation: further developments in the lexical approach, in
M. Lewis, Ed. London: Language Teaching Publication, 2000, pp28-46.
[57] S. Ying, ‘’Study on collocations in English writing by Chinese
students’’ in Sino -US English Teaching 6,3, 2009, pp25-30.
[58] C. Yumanee, & S. Phoocharoensil, ‘’Analysis of Collocation Errors of
Thai EFL Students’’ in Journal of Education and Practice , 2, 3, 2011,
pp 90-100
[59] M.R. Zughol, & H.S. Abdul- Fattah, ‘’Collocation competence of Arabic
speaking learners of English: A study in lexical semantics’’ 2001,
(Online) Available:
http://eric.ed.gov/ERICDocs/data/ericdocs2sql/content_storage_01/0000
019b/80/1b/4f/28.pd