A Review on the Development and Challenges of Green Roof Systems in Malaysia

Green roof system is considered a relatively new
concept in Malaysia even though it has been implemented widely in
the developed countries. Generally, green roofs provide many
benefits such as enhancing aesthetical quality of the built
environment, reduce urban heat island effect, reduce energy
consumption, improve stormwater attenuation, and reduce noise
pollution. A better understanding on the implementation of green roof
system in Malaysia is crucial, as Malaysia’s climate is different if
compared with the climate in temperate countries where most of the
green roof studies have been conducted. This study has concentrated
on the technical aspect of green roof system which focuses on i) types
of plants and method of planting; ii) engineering design for green
roof system; iii) its hydrological performance on reducing stormwater
runoff; and iv) benefits of green roofs with respect to energy.
Literature review has been conducted to identify the development and
obstacles associated with green roofs systems in Malaysia. The study
had identified the challenges and potentials of green roofs
development in Malaysia. This study also provided the
recommendations on standard design and strategies on the
implementation of green roofs in Malaysia in the near future.

Authors:

• M. F. Chow
• M. F. Abu Bakar

Keywords:

• Engineering design
• green roof
• sustainable development
• tropical countries.

References:

[1] Yusof, M., & Johari, M. 2012. Identifying Green Spaces in Kuala
Lumpur Using Higher Resolution Satellite Imagery. ALAM CIPTA
UPM: International Journal of Sustainable Tropical Design Research &
Practice, 5:93-106.
[2] United Nations (2002),”World Urbanization Prospects: The 2001
Revision”. United Nations, New York.
[3] Aziz, N. A. A. 2012. Green Space Use and Management in Malaysia.
Forest and Landscape Research, No 51-2012. Forest & Landscape
Denmark, Frederiksberg. 127
[4] Stone Jr., B., (2004),”Paving over paradise: how land use regulations
promote residential imperviousness”, Landscape and Urban Planning 69,
101–113.
[5] Timothy L. Carter and Todd C. Rasmussen (2005),“Use Of Green Roofs
For Ultra-Urban Stream Restoration In The Georgia Piedmont (USA)”
Greening Rooftops for Sustainable Communities, proceedings. May
2005, Washington D.C.
[6] Urban Stormwater Management Manual (2001), Department of
Irrigation and Drainage Malaysia. Malaysia Government.
[7] Moran, A., B. Hunt, and G. Jennings. (2003), “A North Carolina Field
Study To Evaluate Greenroof Runoff Quality, Runoff Quantity and Plant
Growth”. ASAE Paper, American Society of Agriculture Engineering,
USA.
[8] Liptan, T. (2003),” Planning, zoning and financial incentives for
ecoroofs in Portland, Oregon”. page 113–120. In Proc. of 1st North
American Green Roof Conf.: Greening Rooftops for Sustainable
Communities, Chicago. 29–30 May 2003. The Cardinal Group, Toronto.
[9] I. Asmat, A. S. Muna Hanim, and A. R. Abdul Malek, “ Using Green
Roof As a passive Design Technology To Minimise the Impact of Global Warming,” 2nd Int. Conf. Built Environ. Dev. Ctries. (ICBEDC
2008), no. Icbedc, pp. 588-598, 2008
[10] WERTHMANN, C. (2007) Green Roof - A Case Study: Michael Van
Valkenburgh Associates' Design for the Headquaters of the American
Society of Landscape Architects, New York, Princeton Architectural
Press.
[11] Wong NH, Chen Y, Ong CL, Sia A. Investigation of thermal benefits of
rooftop garden in the tropical environment. Building Environ
2003;38(2):261-270.
[12] N. Kamarulzaman, S. Z. Hashim, H. Hashim, and A. A. Saleh, “Green
Roof Concpet as a Passive Cooling Approach in Tropical Climate- An
Overview.” vol. 8, 2014.
[13] Liptan, T and Strecker, E (2003), Ecoroofs (Greenroofs) – A More
Sustainable Infrastructure”, Bureau of Environmental Services, Portland
Oregon, USA.
[14] Jeroen Mentens, Dirk Raes dan Martin Hermy (2005),“Green roofs as a
tool for solving the rainwater runoff problem in the urbanized 21st
century?” Landscape and Urban Planning 77 (2006), 217–226.
[15] S. Musa, M. Arish, N. Arshad, M. Jalil, and H. Kasmin, “Potential of
Storm Water Capacity Using Vegetated Roofs in Malaysia.” Int. Conf.
Civ. Eng. Pract. 08, 2011
[16] Theodosiou, T. G. (2003) Summer period analysis of the performance of
a planted roof as a passive cooling technique. Energy and Buildings, 35,
909-917.
[17] General Service Administration. (2011). The benefits and challenges of
green roofs on public and commercial buildings. A report of the United
States General Services Administration.
[18] O, Saadatian, K. Sopian, E. Salleh, C.H. Lim, Safa Riffat, Elham
Saadatian, Arash Toudeshki, M.Y. Sulaiman. (2013). A review of
energy aspects of green roofs. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews. 23: 155-168.
[19] N. Kamarulzaman, S.Z. Hashim, H. Hashim, A.A. Saleh. (2014). Green
roof concepts as a passive cooling approach in tropical climate – an
overview. E3s Web of Conferences 3, 01028. Pp. 1-7.
[20] S. Rafida, A. Rahman, and H. Ahmad, “Green Roof As Urban Antidote:
a Review on Aesthetic, Environmental, Economic and Social Benefits,”
6th South East Asian Tech. Univ. Consort Symp., p. 4,2008.
[21] M.H. Md. Zahir, S.N. Raman, M.F. Mohamed, M. Jamiland, Z.M.
Nopiah. (2014). The perception of Malaysian Architects towards the
implementation of green roofs: a review of practices, methodologies and
future research. E3S Web of Conferences 3, 01022.
[22] Ismail, A., Samad, M.-H.-A., and Rahman, A.-M.-A., (2008). Using
green roof concept as a passive design technology to minimize the
impact of global warming. Proceeding of 2nd International Conference
on built environment in Developing countries (ICBEDC 2008). Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia.
[23] H.A. Aziz and Z. Ismail. (2011). Design Guideline for Sustainable
Green Roof System. In the Proceeding of 2011 IEEE Symposium on
Business, Engineering and Industrial Application (ISBEIA). Langkawi,
Malaysia.
[24] Ismail, A., Samad, M.-H.-A., and Rahman, A.-M.-A., 2011. The
investigation of green roof and white roof cooling potential on single
storey residential building in the Malaysian climate. International
Journal of Civil, Structural, Construction and Architectural Engineering,
5 (4): 20–28.
[25] Johari, J., Rashid, M.H., and Said, I., 2011. Planting technology of green
roof for building in tropical cities: a review on plant selection. 5th South
East Asian technical university consortium symposium. Hanoi.
[26] Kok, K.H., L.M. Sidek, M.F. Chow, M.R.Z. Abidin, H. Basri, G. Hayder
(2015). Evaluation of green roof performances for urban stormwater
quantity and quality controls. International Journal of River Basin
Management. 1-7.
[27] A. Shaharuddin, M.H. noorazuan, M.J. Yaakob. (2011). Green roofs as
best management practices for heat reduction and stormwater flow
mitigation. World applied Sciences Journal 13 (Sustainable
Development Impact from the Socio-Environmental Perspectives): 58-
62.
[28] Musa, Sabariah and Mohd Arish @ Arshad, Nor Aini and Jalil, Mas
Rahayu and Kasmin, Hartini and Ali, Zarina and Mansor, Mohd
Shukri (2008). Potential of storm water capacity using vegetated roofs
in malaysia. In: International Conference on Civil Engineering Practice
(ICCE08), Hyatt Regency Kuantan Resort, Kuantan, Pahang.
[29] Kasmin, H., Stovin, V., and De-Ville, S., 2014. Evaluation of green roof
hydrological performance in a Malaysian context. Proceeding of 14th
international conference on urban drainage (ICUD 2014), 7–12
September 2014. Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
[30] Shahid, K.A., Sulaiman, M.A., Ghazali, N., Rahman, A.W., Zukri, A.
(2013). Palm oil clinker as drainage layer in green roof system under
Malaysia climatic conditions. In proceeding of Malaysian Technical
Universities Conference on Engineering & Technology (MUCET).
[31] Ismail, Z., Aziz, H.A., Nasir, N.M., Taib, M.M.Z. (2012). Obstacles to
adopt green roof in Malaysia. In proceeding of IEEE Colloquium on
Humanities, Science & Engineering Research (CHUSER 2012), 3-4
December 2012, Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, Malaysia. Pp. 357-361.
[32] W. Zuriea, et al., "Perception Towards Green Roof in Malaysia," in
Management in Construction Researchers Association (MiCRA), Faculty
of Architecture, Planning & Surveying UiTM Shah Alam, 2010, pp. 97-
104.
[33] Ismail, Z., Aziz, A. H., Nasir, M. N., & Taib, M. Z. M. 2012.
Comparative Study on Green Roof Mechanism in Developed Countries.
Proceedings of the 2012 IEEE Symposium on Business, Engineering
and Industrial Applications, 678-683.
[34] Herman, R. 2003. Green Roofs in Germany: Yesterday, Today and
Tomorrow. Proceedings of the 1st North American Green Roof
Conference: Greening Rooftops for Sustainable Communities, Chicago,
II. Vol. 32 (22): 41-45.